The

smiley is a strong smiley, man. It's hurtful, you know.
I'm a Marchisio critic from way back. This forum has debated his efficacy for half a decade. I don't doubt that he has a great football brain, and that that counts for a lot more than people are willing or able to acknowledge. He brings a lot of calm and stability to the midfield especially as a regista. He's smart enough to lose his marker (and since that lost tie against Munich some years ago, where Pirlo was marked out of the game, Juve's holding mid is always paid close attention) and get onto the ball as much as possible. That in itself is integral to a functioning midfield. Not to mention that he works hard and covers the defense which refreshingly contrasted Pirlo's approach.
But we can't over rate him either. His first season under Conte was the best in his career. He was actually the protagonist in a lot of games, scoring several great goals. It was the only really consistently excellent season he's played in my memory. Since then, as a holding mid, he's waxed and waned between quietly brilliant and typically mediocre performances - no massive blunders, but no notable attempts to take the game on either. Most people would characterize him and a 7-8/10 in everything, but he excels in very little. He's not particularly creative and he doesn't try to be. He works hard to cover the defense but he's not physically very dominant either. Once in a blue moon he'll do something that gets you off your seat in applause. But it doesn't happen very often.
I like Lemina a lot and I've got high hopes for him because he's not afraid to do those things that Marchisio won't. He'll break forward and make things happen by taking risks, dribbling past his markers or trying a difficult pass. He's also more physically imposing than Marchisio. He can bully players off the ball as well as anyone in our midfield. So, if he can start to move more intelligently and get on the ball as much as Marchisio, I think he'll challenge to start one day. That's the only thing he trails Marchisio in (as well as experience), but he trails him by a lot.
Making key passes is a minimal requirement for a holding mid, but they really should make some contribution in goals and assists throughout the season as well. Pirlo made tons of assists and Lemina, with very limited playing time managed to find the net a few times. He took the responsibility to push forward and make the difference and I reckon if he stays fit all next season he's going to grow into a real player.
SORRY FOR THE ESSAYS LATELY EVERYBODY lol in b4 "did not read"