A Blame of Thrones: Mafia Game (13 Viewers)

Alen

Ѕenior Аdmin
Apr 2, 2007
53,923
It was day 1. Any choice is justifiable. She wasn't going to be crucified for going for Bezzy.
Even if so. If Hoori voted Janna, it was gonna be 3:2 (Janna:Hoori). Even if the others didn't vote for Hoori at that point, Janna was gonna vote Hoori, just to protect herself. It was gonna be 3:3 and a 50% chance to die for Hoori.
Hoori simply protected herself by not voting for Janna.
 
OP
Kate

Kate

Moderator
Feb 7, 2011
18,595
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #924
    Salvo - Hoori
    Tomice - Hoori
    Voeller - Hoori
    Jihadi John - Hoori

    Bezzy - Fred
    Alen - Fred
    NinjaPoggy - Fred

    ALC - Jihadi John

    Hængebøffer - piotrr

    piotrr - Alen

    Fred is in jail and his vote does not count.

    Hoori, Monco, WΏΏdy left to vote.
     

    Alen

    Ѕenior Аdmin
    Apr 2, 2007
    53,923
    Yet that is funny Alen. Look back in this thread. Hoori claimed to me that it wasn't to save her ass but rather because she became suddenly convinced that Radekas was a G.
    Knowing Hoori, that's also possible.

    I can't claim that Hoori isn't a G. But you'll need to base that on something else, not on her day 1 voting.
     

    Salvo

    J
    Moderator
    Dec 17, 2007
    62,791
    Even if so. If Hoori voted Janna, it was gonna be 3:2 (Janna:Hoori). Even if the others didn't vote for Hoori at that point, Janna was gonna vote Hoori, just to protect herself. It was gonna be 3:3 and a 50% chance to die for Hoori.
    Hoori simply protected herself by not voting for Janna.
    Maybe. Maybe not. But as a C, who is going for the most likely G apparently. You go for the target you kept talking about. Bezzy. At least IMO
     

    Tomice

    Senior Member
    Mar 25, 2009
    3,024
    They both could have been G's as unlikely as it sounds, there were so many inactive players at the time that the voting was so tight even with 3 votes max on one person he could be beyond saving

    Another possibility, as slim as it might, like I've suggested before is that Janna could be a special role C and the G's got to her and she became a valuable puppet the the G's thought was worth the effort to save

    Also alen, there is no way she could have been this calculated when there was so much pressure and the clock was ticking, her making such a great vote with all those factors she mantioned makes me find it very unlikely, unless she had help to get there
     

    Alen

    Ѕenior Аdmin
    Apr 2, 2007
    53,923
    And will the detective for once find a G? Whenever I play lately, the D always investigates civilians :(

    We're helpless here.

    - - - Updated - - -

    They both could have been G's as unlikely as it sounds,
    By "both" you mean Hoori and Janna?

    Close to impossible, because even if there were indeen many inactives, dying with 2 votes was impossible for those two if they were both Gs.
    If nothing else, both were active and present. They could both put their votes on one of those 9 others who had only 1 vote and kill him with 3 votes.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Also alen, there is no way she could have been this calculated when there was so much pressure and the clock was ticking, her making such a great vote with all those factors she mantioned makes me find it very unlikely, unless she had help to get there
    Hoori gave her vote with only 2 minutes remaining, but that only shows when she finally gave the vote. If she was calculating, she was doing it prior to the vote.
    I'm convinced that Hoori was aware it won't end well if she votes for Janna. And once again, this doesn't mean Hoori isn't a G. She might be. But she simply knew that voting for Janna was bad for her.
     

    Tomice

    Senior Member
    Mar 25, 2009
    3,024
    Hoori gave her vote with only 2 minutes remaining, but that only shows when she finally gave the vote. If she was calculating, she was doing it prior to the vote.
    I'm convinced that Hoori was aware it won't end well if she votes for Janna. And once again, this doesn't mean Hoori isn't a G. She might be. But she simply knew that voting for Janna was bad for her.
    Not accurate

    Am I being voted out? :lol:
    She only found out at 22:46.

    Only ten minutes later I voted Janna, making it 2 for Janna. It means that prior to that it wasn't even an option

    That leaves her with around 4-5 minutes to make all those calculations, alone, and get it perfect
     

    Salvo

    J
    Moderator
    Dec 17, 2007
    62,791
    Not accurate



    She only found out at 22:46.

    Only ten minutes later I voted Janna, making it 2 for Janna. It means that prior to that it wasn't even an option

    That leaves her with around 4-5 minutes to make all those calculations, alone, and get it perfect
    Exactly. So why Radekas? She wasn't saving herself at that point.
     

    Alen

    Ѕenior Аdmin
    Apr 2, 2007
    53,923
    Not accurate



    She only found out at 22:46.

    Only ten minutes later I voted Janna, making it 2 for Janna. It means that prior to that it wasn't even an option

    That leaves her with around 4-5 minutes to make all those calculations, alone, and get it perfect
    Ok then.

    But I still find it impossible that a G risked lynching with only 2 votes.
    Again, why didn't Hoori simply vote Janna? And if it was because Janna's a G, then why didn't Janna and Hoori simply vote for the same person?

    If there was a semi suspicious vote that night, it's Fred's. When all three of Hoori, Janna and Radekas had 2 votes, Fred gave the decisive 3rd vote in the very last minute. That makes him more suspicious than Hoori.
     

    Tomice

    Senior Member
    Mar 25, 2009
    3,024
    Again, why didn't Hoori simply vote Janna? And if it was because Janna's a G, then why didn't Janna and Hoori simply vote for the same person?

    If there was a semi suspicious vote that night, it's Fred's. When all three of Hoori, Janna and Radekas had 2 votes, Fred gave the decisive 3rd vote in the very last minute. That makes him more suspicious than Hoori.
    Regarding your first point I don't know, with all of us trying to make sense of it while it can be because Janna was away bird watching. if Janna his a G, she wasn't in danger until I voted with five minutes to go, it can be as simple as she missed it cause there was no vote count.

    I agree with you second point although you are missing my point, I was suspecting Fred for his vote as well and wasn't shy about it, still am. My point was that Hoori overdid it, she couldn't have had all those reasons in mind when she voted and her using all of them and trying to give the impression that they all were actual considerations she took realtime seem far fetched.
     

    Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 13)