[WC] World Cup 2010 - General Talk Thread (42 Viewers)

BillyG

Caribbean Ultra
Nov 25, 2006
4,151
It's not fine by me. The game is so fast nowadays that it's all about inches. If they get it wrong, it changes everything. Italy deserved to go out obviously, but Uruguay didn't. And some of the wrong offisde calls today weren't even close. I remember a call against Kuyt and one against Uruguay.. so so poor.
but then it can be argued that they did deserve to go out considering the incidents in the game against ghana!

no matter which call you want to pick on, ur gonna open a pandora's box of officiating errors that go all the way back to the initial group games or even back to qualifying (ala france)
 

Seven

In bocca al lupo, Fabio.
Jun 25, 2003
39,343
but then it can be argued that they did deserve to go out considering the incidents in the game against ghana!

no matter which call you want to pick on, ur gonna open a pandora's box of officiating errors that go all the way back to the initial group games or even back to qualifying (ala france)
That's my point. There's no way of knowing how games would have gone. What you're left with now is only the certainty that this is not the way things would have gone had the right calls been made. Holland might have reached the final anyway, they might also not have. France might have qualified, they might not have. Mexico might have won against Argentina, they might not have. England might have won against Germany, they might not have. The only thing that is certain is that with the right calls, the games would have been different. If the outcome would have been different, we cannot know.

I can say though that this World Cup should be the beginning of the use of technology. If it isn't, the game is going to die. You cannot expect a linesman to get all the calls right today, because the players are moving so fast, the ball is moving so fast and everyone is doing anything they can to somehow get an advantage. If you don't help the referees right now, they will become the ones who will decide everything in five or ten years time. Not because they want to decide anything, but because their actions will be completely random.
 

Oggy

and the Cockroaches
Dec 27, 2005
7,514
One of the following won't be able to play in my FF team because there's no space: Podolski, Klose, Villa. Who do I bench? Suggestions please!
Same problem here, Van Persie and Kuyt already played and got 7pts., so now I'm between Villa and Poldi. Also I'm between Ramos, Capdevilla and Lahm for defence, only two of them can play, or I could throw out Ozil or Schweini and play all three at the back... So much dilemma...
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 42)