Was Juve's relegation fair? (4 Viewers)

Was Juve's relegation fair?

  • We were lucky not to be relegated to Serie C or lower

  • It was so fair

  • We deserved to stay in Serie A with points deducted

  • No, it was a conspiracy

  • I don't know


Results are only viewable after voting.

denco

Superior Being
Jul 12, 2002
4,679
#43
Wow what a totally genial thing to bring up. A poll in a juventus forum regarding whether it was fair to relegate Juventus, why stop there, lets go to Inter's website and ask if Juve deserved to be relegated or they deserved the scudetto this season. The purpose of a poll is to have some kind of objectivity not something that will come up with a unanimous decision.
From my perspective, Juventus did not deserve to be relegated as it has not done a single thing . A better poll and should be in an Italian football clubs website and should be along the lines of whether the relegation of Juventus actually achieved anything in terms of cleaning up Italian football
 
OP

ReBeL

The Jackal
Jan 14, 2005
22,871
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #44
    Wow what a totally genial thing to bring up. A poll in a juventus forum regarding whether it was fair to relegate Juventus, why stop there, lets go to Inter's website and ask if Juve deserved to be relegated or they deserved the scudetto this season. The purpose of a poll is to have some kind of objectivity not something that will come up with a unanimous decision.
    From my perspective, Juventus did not deserve to be relegated as it has not done a single thing . A better poll and should be in an Italian football clubs website and should be along the lines of whether the relegation of Juventus actually achieved anything in terms of cleaning up Italian football
    So, we can not say our opinion because we're all Juve fans.

    Nice logic.
     

    JCK

    Biased
    JCK
    May 11, 2004
    125,390
    #46
    Wow what a totally genial thing to bring up. A poll in a juventus forum regarding whether it was fair to relegate Juventus, why stop there, lets go to Inter's website and ask if Juve deserved to be relegated or they deserved the scudetto this season. The purpose of a poll is to have some kind of objectivity not something that will come up with a unanimous decision.
    From my perspective, Juventus did not deserve to be relegated as it has not done a single thing . A better poll and should be in an Italian football clubs website and should be along the lines of whether the relegation of Juventus actually achieved anything in terms of cleaning up Italian football
    Shall I close the thread?
     

    denco

    Superior Being
    Jul 12, 2002
    4,679
    #47
    Shall I close the thread?
    Its not for me to say, if you feel it would be a fair poll then by all means let it stand but I personally do not see how a Juventus fan is expected to be objective and noone can blame them for it. A more objective poll would be something along the lines of did relegation change Juventus board's way of thinking or which player benefitted the most from Juventus promotion in terms of showing qualities that we would never have seen if all our world class players did not leave
     

    Vinman

    2013 Prediction Cup Champ
    Jul 16, 2002
    11,482
    #48
    Wow what a totally genial thing to bring up. A poll in a juventus forum regarding whether it was fair to relegate Juventus, why stop there, lets go to Inter's website and ask if Juve deserved to be relegated or they deserved the scudetto this season. The purpose of a poll is to have some kind of objectivity not something that will come up with a unanimous decision.
    From my perspective, Juventus did not deserve to be relegated as it has not done a single thing . A better poll and should be in an Italian football clubs website and should be along the lines of whether the relegation of Juventus actually achieved anything in terms of cleaning up Italian football

    :agree:
     

    X Æ A-12

    Senior Member
    Contributor
    Sep 4, 2006
    87,971
    #49
    i think that even if juve was guilty we didnt deserve to be relegated while every other team got point deuctions which most were useless
     

    swag

    L'autista
    Administrator
    Sep 23, 2003
    84,788
    #50
    It was a fair punishment to us, but an unfair punishment given to every other club implicated ... or not implicated.
     

    d.nico

    Senior Member
    Apr 23, 2003
    2,244
    #51
    It was a fair punishment to us, but an unfair punishment given to every other club implicated ... or not implicated.
    fair and unfair is relative. if the punishment for one side is different from the others and the punihment is heavier than others, we can say it's unfair.
     

    JCK

    Biased
    JCK
    May 11, 2004
    125,390
    #52
    Its not for me to say, if you feel it would be a fair poll then by all means let it stand but I personally do not see how a Juventus fan is expected to be objective and noone can blame them for it. A more objective poll would be something along the lines of did relegation change Juventus board's way of thinking or which player benefitted the most from Juventus promotion in terms of showing qualities that we would never have seen if all our world class players did not leave
    When did we have a fair poll on this site anyway?
     

    denco

    Superior Being
    Jul 12, 2002
    4,679
    #57
    When did we have a fair poll on this site anyway?
    There are some okay ones but I have seen some incredible ones like lets vote for the person who was most effective for Lyon winning their 6th consecutive title. Boggles the mind, dont it? Thats like going to a snoop fan club and asking for his fans to vote for their favourite Beach boys song
     

    Snoop

    Sabet is a nasty virgin
    Oct 2, 2001
    28,186
    #59
    There are some okay ones but I have seen some incredible ones like lets vote for the person who was most effective for Lyon winning their 6th consecutive title. Boggles the mind, dont it? Thats like going to a snoop fan club and asking for his fans to vote for their favourite Beach boys song
    don't get me wrong, but you have to take this forum less seriously, we have lots of fools around, and you can't change them. these polls are only fun, wasting some time, it will not change anything. But still you can find some members that you can discuss football, that's all.
     

    Chxta

    Onye kwe, Chi ya ekwe
    Nov 1, 2004
    12,088
    #60
    We did something wrong, but the relegation was unfair. We should have stayed up with a few points deducted.
     

    Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 4)