The Greatest Songwriter Of All Time (1 Viewer)

[HelterSkelter]

Who would you go for?

It would be Paul McCartney for me.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Snoop]

Not Elton John for sure.

 

[Rami]

Bob Dylan?

 

[HelterSkelter]

Not Elton John for sure.

He would very easily be up there with the best.

Bob Dylan?

Good choice

 

[Zé Tahir]

RZA

 

[V]

Another impossible pick. You have a lot of those, Salman.

 

[HelterSkelter]

@Tahir

Isnt he more of a producer than a songwriter?

 

[HelterSkelter]

Another impossible pick. You have a lot of those, Salman.

You just have poor decision making skills

 

[JCK]

In what genre? you can't say that Jim Morrison is the greatest and disregard Bob Marley for example.

 

[Red]

Who would you go for?

It would be Paul McCartney for me.

Why McCartney over John Lennon?

I'm not necessarily disagreeing, I'm just curious.

 

[Zé Tahir]

@Tahir

Isnt he more of a producer than a songwriter?

Perhaps, but his lyrics are ill I wasn't serious...I mean he's damn good but I can't say who's the greatest of all time.

 

[V]

Why McCartney over John Lennon?

I'm not necessarily disagreeing, I'm just curious.

Yet neither wrote the bestest Beatles song ever.

 

[Zé Tahir]

The Beatles are overrated.

 

[V]

 

[HelterSkelter]

In what genre? you can't say that Jim Morrison is the greatest and disregard Bob Marley for example.

No specific genre.Just generally speaking.A songwriter who you think has had a more significant influence over music globally regardless of genre..over everyone else

Why McCartney over John Lennon?

I'm not necessarily disagreeing, I'm just curious.

I think McCartney had this natural knack for Rhythm.A phenomenal natural ability.Lennon had it too,but i just think McCartney was more gifted.Comparing the two would be unfair since Lennon died early and McCartney had a brilliant post Beatles career..but i've heard their post Beatles stuff,and i have to say that i enjoy McCartney's material much more.

 

[.zero]

tupac shakur






























no wait he was a convicted rapist, nevermind

 

[HelterSkelter]

Yet neither wrote the bestest Beatles song ever.

While my guitar gently weeps?

 

[Red]

Yet neither wrote the bestest Beatles song ever.

Which was?

 

[V]

Salman got it. Neither comes close, in my humble opinion.

 

[Red]

I think McCartney had this natural knack for Rhythm.A phenomenal natural ability.Lennon had it too,but i just think McCartney was more gifted.Comparing the two would be unfair since Lennon died early and McCartney had a brilliant post Beatles career..but i've heard their post Beatles stuff,and i have to say that i enjoy McCartney's material much more.

Fair enough.

I'm not going to say Lennon was better, but I preferred his post-Beatles stuff to McCartney's.