Summer mercato 2015 (45 Viewers)

Status
Not open for further replies.

baggio

Senior Member
Jun 3, 2003
19,250
Calibre of player ? Is that what you were saying regarding Morata last yr ?

Morata now is one of the top young strikers in Europe.

Draxler was/is a highly touted young player but the injury has halted his progress by a bit.If we can mould him into a world class player,would you question his calibre ?
You don't have the bandwidth or security of last year with the departures of Tevez, Pirlo and Vidal to take a chance on a player who is coming off an injury and doesn't even play CAM at the moment for the position that you want. Keep in mind you're already taking a chance on Dybala at 32m plus 8m bonuses. A new cycle doesn't necessarily have to be this risky because we are doing this from a position of strength and not being forced to.

- - - Updated - - -

so we have to convince pogba to stay by signing world class players? Is that how it works?
Of course, you have to keep your players energised and motivated by showing them a certain mentality. Pogba for example is a world class talent. He will understand how possible it is to win the CL with Juve soon enough whether Draxler arrives or zgoetze and his decision to move will also keep that in mind. Morata too.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Cheesio

**********
Jul 11, 2006
22,514
so we have to convince pogba to stay by signing world class players? Is that how it works?
By improving the team, by building on last year result, by being a CL protagonist every year. That would allow you to keep your best players and sign the world best players...

The way i see it is that we had a great team, a good core, yes some of our players are old but if noticed we didn't replace any of our players, the defence is still old, so why not sign 2 proven players and try your luck again in the CL, do the management think we went as fas as we could with this group.

We must wait for Dybala, Draxler...to turn into WC players to have a chance at winning the CL again, you replaced Tevez with Dybala that's good, why sell Vidal, and if you do why not replace him with proven players who could fill the gap right away.
Like i said before, i would've understand the Vidal sale if we got a WC AM, and a great LB ( Coentrao, Sandro...)
My fear is that the Vidal sale was to balance the books and we won't invest the money back.
o
 

KB824

Senior Member
Sep 16, 2003
31,789
You don't have the bandwidth or security of last year with the departures of Tevez, Pirlo and Vidal to take a chance on a player who is coming off an injury and doesn't even play CAM at the moment for the position that you want. Keep in mind you're already taking a chance on Dybala at 32m plus 8m bonuses.

You have Morata who is a year older. You have Mandzukic coming on board to provide the toughness and workrate. You have Dybala who has Serie A experience with a very high ceiling.

You have Zaza................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................

............................................................................................................................................................................................. still thinking of something nice to say.............................................................................................................................................................. You have Zaza.

The attack is going to be different for sure, but it is not bereft of quality. I think that anyone can see that.

The center of the midfield is already exponentially better with Marchisio instead of Pirlo.

One of Khedira, Asamoah, or Pereyra can move into that midfield spot of Vidal's. Different characteristics, yes, but quality nonetheless.

I think everyone is awfully wrapped up in the image that the sale of Vidal, and Tevez and Pirlo's departures signify. Players leave all the time, and the only unexpected one out of the bunch was Vidal, but again unexpected transfers happen very very often. I mean nearly everyone by the end of the season was begging for Pirlo to be benched.

- - - Updated - - -

By improving the team, by building on last year result, by being a CL protagonist every year. That would allow you to keep your best players and sign the world best players...

The way i see it is that we had a great team, a good core, yes some of our players are old but if noticed we didn't replace any of our players, the defence is still old, so why not sign 2 proven players and try your luck again in the CL, do the management think we went as fas as we could with this group.

We must wait for Dybala, Draxler...to turn into WC players to have a chance at winning the CL again, you replaced Tevez with Dybala that's good, why sell Vidal, and if you do why not replace him with proven players who could fill the gap right away.
Like i said before, i would've understand the Vidal sale if we got a WC AM, and a great LB ( Coentrao, Sandro...)
My fear is that the Vidal sale was to balance the books and we won't invest the money back.
o
When was the last time Juve signed a World Class player? Think about that for a second. Not a player that they signed that they helped turn into World Class, not a player that was once considered World Class whose career they resurrected, but an actual bonafide world class player that was signed at the peak of his abilities?
 
Jul 20, 2012
20,044
By improving the team, by building on last year result, by being a CL protagonist every year. That would allow you to keep your best players and sign the world best players...

The way i see it is that we had a great team, a good core, yes some of our players are old but if noticed we didn't replace any of our players, the defence is still old, so why not sign 2 proven players and try your luck again in the CL, do the management think we went as fas as we could with this group.

We must wait for Dybala, Draxler...to turn into WC players to have a chance at winning the CL again, you replaced Tevez with Dybala that's good, why sell Vidal, and if you do why not replace him with proven players who could fill the gap right away.
Like i said before, i would've understand the Vidal sale if we got a WC AM, and a great LB ( Coentrao, Sandro...)
My fear is that the Vidal sale was to balance the books and we won't invest the money back.
o
But we arent in the position and never were about buying world class players. So i think everyone should just forget about this signing big name players

- - - Updated - - -

When was the last time Juve signed a World Class player? Think about that for a second. Not a player that they signed that they helped turn into World Class, not a player that was once considered World Class whose career they resurrected, but an actual bonafide world class player that was signed at the peak of his abilities?
This
 

Cheesio

**********
Jul 11, 2006
22,514
When was the last time Juve signed a World Class player? Think about that for a second. Not a player that they signed that they helped turn into World Class, not a player that was once considered World Class whose career they resurrected, but an actual bonafide world class player that was signed at the peak of his abilities?
Football has changed tough, Italy used to have talented players that we could buy cheaply and they would deliver, not the case tough right now. And i'm not talking about paying record breaking fees. All i am saying is that we should operate smartly and use the result we had last year both financially and on the pitch to improve not spend insane money on average player wich we don't need.
You have Morata who had a great year and destined to be one of the best CF in the world and you go spend 40 mil on two players who should be his backups ?? you sell Vidal for 40 mil and we don't sign a proven AM ?? why didn't we imrpove our FullBacks ?? what formation would we play ??

A lot of question marks for next season, and before people jump on me saying the mang should get the benefit of doubt, i totally agree doesn't mean i shouldn't have my doubts.
 

KB824

Senior Member
Sep 16, 2003
31,789
Football has changed tough, Italy used to have talented players that we could buy cheaply and they would deliver, not the case tough right now. And i'm not talking about paying record breaking fees. All i am saying is that we should operate smartly and use the result we had last year both financially and on the pitch to improve not spend insane money on average player wich we don't need.
You have Morata who had a great year and destined to be one of the best CF in the world and you go spend 40 mil on two players who should be his backups ?? you sell Vidal for 40 mil and we don't sign a proven AM ?? why didn't we imrpove our FullBacks ?? what formation would we play ??

A lot of question marks for next season, and before people jump on me saying the mang should get the benefit of doubt, i totally agree doesn't mean i shouldn't have my doubts.
Cheesio, it is July 26th, my man.
 

Valerio.

Senior Member
Jul 5, 2014
5,767
Cheesio, it is July 26th, my man.
And we're already over booked in attack. Exactly where we needed quality over quantity.
Economically speaking this is crap. Cause we know that we'll buy an AM and you already have 5 strikers (Coman,Morata,Dybala,Mandzukic and Zaza).
Where if we wanted to play with 4-3-1-2 4 were enough adding the AM.
Last year Llorente,Matri and Coman played really really few games. What's the point of brining 3 strikers when one of the 2 spot is already taken by Morata? Because this means we spent at least 40m for 2 benchers.
Going by how much we spent ..... Next year attack will be Morata-Dybala with an unknown AM behind them. Leaving Mandzukic (19m and 3,5m wage) and Zaza (18m and 1,8m wage) and Coman on the bench.
Can you explain me what's the logic in that? and instead of 2 benchers why we didn't bring a single stronger player? leaving some chances for Coman.
So unless we're going to play 4-3-3 this is pure madeness.
 

zizinho

Senior Member
Apr 14, 2013
51,816
If we mentioned Gotze earlier in the Summer, you would have said he'd be out of reach.

Now that we are linked with him, you're saying that he wants to stay with his childhood team.
for any player we are linked with we must know if the club is willing to sell the player. if the club would sell, then you must know if the player himself does want to come here. in Gotzes situation, as you mentioned earlier this mercato "we" would say "out of reach". why was he out of reach though? because Bayern didnt want to let him go. right now, for whatever reason, Bayern gave us the permission to talk to the player and we did. we made contacts and it is up to Gotze right now, if he wants to leave, Bayern will sell to us and we can get him, if not, you can offer 80M and he would still not come here.

but why did you qoute me? did you want to answer my question or what?
 

KB824

Senior Member
Sep 16, 2003
31,789
And we're already over booked in attack. Exactly where we needed quality over quantity.
Economically speaking this is crap. Cause we know that we'll buy an AM and you already have 5 strikers (Coman,Morata,Dybala,Mandzukic and Zaza).
Where if we wanted to play with 4-3-1-2 4 were enough adding the AM.
Last year Llorente,Matri and Coman played really really few games. What's the point of brining 3 strikers when one of the 2 spot is already taken by Morata? Because this means we spent at least 40m for 2 benchers.
Going by how much we spent ..... Next year attack will be Morata-Dybala with an unknown AM behind them. Leaving Mandzukic (19m and 3,5m wage) and Zaza (18m and 1,8m wage) and Coman on the bench.
Can you explain me what's the logic in that? and instead of 2 benchers why we didn't bring a single stronger player? leaving some chances for Coman.
So unless we're going to play 4-3-3 this is pure madeness.
Who says they can't play both a 4-3-3 and a 4-3-1-2 depending on the situation? The last thing that any coach wants is to have players who only fit one formation. And that is why I think there is another reason why Draxler is being looked at, aside from an economic point of view. He can play both wing positions as well as an AM.
 

Hust

Senior Member
Hustini
May 29, 2005
93,703
Who says they can't play both a 4-3-3 and a 4-3-1-2 depending on the situation? The last thing that any coach wants is to have players who only fit one formation. And that is why I think there is another reason why Draxler is being looked at, aside from an economic point of view. He can play both wing positions as well as an AM.
Tactical flexibility. Our team has it. Can't wait to see if we get Draxler.
 

AndreaCristiano

Nato, Vive, e muore Italiano
Jun 9, 2011
19,126
@AlexJuventino: Last time I checked Goetze isn't exactly happy with how Bayern are treating him, nor is he Guardiola's blue eyed boy. Anyway, was not comparing them either. Was alluding to the fact that it's not impossible to sign a top player. Some of us have stopped believing that. Right now we are discussing Draxler, but if instead of him we were signing Mhiktarayan, I'm sure I'd still here the same reasoning. 'Who else can we sign'? That is an issue for me because I think our notion is to just accept this mindset which is not necessarily right just because the club is doing it. We have four years of scudetto winning under this management, but we also have a 7th place finish under them, so it's not like they can do absolutely no wrong.
I think you're making a mountain out of a mole hill bro. Just because the will maybe there different deals fall apart for different reasons. I mean if gotze was that unhappy he would have taken the two million pay cut and come somewhere he could be the main guy, but he rather warm the bench and get paid so I have no respect for that . Juventus does whats best for the club all around, not just throwing money out the window. smart moves that not only better the club but keep finances healthy
 

zizinho

Senior Member
Apr 14, 2013
51,816
It started with Oscar, Isco, Goetze goes down to Jovetic and Cuadrado and finally Draxler, so availability is subjective. It's not just player will. The buying club needs to create the conditions to be favourable. Look at how defensive we are sounding 'what's the alternative'? What does that mean? As four time champions of aerie a and a CL finalist, we are asking this question? That too on the back of Marotta himself claiming that top players want to play for us.
Isco was never an option really. Real made it clear he wasnt for sale. if he was he would cost 60M+, which we cant and wont pay. Oscar there was a small chance for him if Chelsea was willing to sell, but they decided he is not and he said he wants to stay there so that settles it. no one can buy these two players right now, not even City or PSG, so better not mention them anymore. as for Jovetic and Cuadrado, we never made it clear that they are our targets. we were just checking if they were available and for how much money. there never was a bid made for them. thats what a lot of clubs do, they ask for information about the player to have a better input before identifying and making the final decision on their targets....

it actually depends a lot on the players will. Gotze right now, from the last news we got, it is all up to him. if he decides to leave, Bayern would let him go. the question is, why would he leave Bayern for the same wages to go abroad, when there is obvious will from the Bayern board to keep him. Guardiola might leave after this season and he would finally be used in his preferred position too. few would leave in that case. it is our job to try to convince him but there is no guarantee he would accept our offer even if we presented brilliant arguments over something as bizarre as wanting to stay in Germany for example.

yes, Marotta claimed top players want to play for us. that doesent mean that ALL top players want to play for us. top players want to play for Real, Ribery, a top player, rejected them in his prime. Khedira, Mandzukic and an uprising star in Dybala. what are those if not top players?

Fiorentina could convince Mario Gomez to make a switch from Bayern but the best Juve can do in such a successful season is Draxler who is perhaps not even the first name that would pop in a CAM discussion given his wider play from the previous two seasons? Common guys. We need to move on from this resigned attitude. When dealing with big clubs and top players we have to ensure we are on top of our game. This is the reality.
Fiorentina and Gomez - they did a good job convincing him to take them over Real, but 1. Bayern wanted to get rid of him and 2. he would be just a backup at Real so that helped the deal too.
are you against Draxler? OK, who would you sign? (you mentioned Anderson, it is weird that there are no links to any teams with him, after such a season, half of Europe isnt all over him? there is something fishy about him, probably already has an agreement with some other team, Bayern probably) we were negotiating with Gotze but unless he makes a change of heart suddenly, he isnt really coming. so who else is there available?

We are all talking about Goetze not wanting to move from his 'boyhood' club, but none of us are making a mention that we are offering him a pay cut to move. Off the top of my mind, Felipe Anderson would be a good move, he may cost us a higher transfer fee (40-45m), but his wages may fall within our parameters. We are asking for loan plus option deals in every big negotiation, don't know what message that sends out in terms of our clarity on that move. Kind of makes me feel we aren't sure when dealing with the big boys. If we can't close a big player after selling a World Class one, with CL money and the best conditions possible in our favour, then this is not going to get better anytime soon. It's no longer a financial outlook, it's a mentality and approach. We are not giving ourselves enough credit as a club. It's almost like we are out of our depth right now, which means we should never have sold Vidal. A core for the new cycle was already in place. His sale has not drastically improved that but has realistically weakened us and lost us the consistency that a Draxler level upstart will not resurrect. But that's another tangent.
-we arent offering him a paycut
-yeah, i mentioned Anderson above, do you think Lazio would sell him for 40M after asking 30M for Candreva last summer? and even with him, would you say for sure he is a better option than Draxler? both are young and both are risks, Draxler at a lower cost is less of a risk though. and you think he would accept lower wages? "yeah, you were offering Draxler 3.5M, give me the same then" would probably be his demand
-we are asking, yes. you cant know if you dont ask. if they say no then we ask for how much the player would cost, and if its too much and we cant negotiate the price down we retreat. i dont see a problem here
-i will repeat this once more: THERE IS NO ONE AVAILABLE. CLUBS WONT SELL THEIR TOP PLAYERS SO EASILY. if a club doesent want to sell there is nothing you can do, so please drop the talk about us not being able to land one. the only players available currently are young upcoming ones that are playing for mid/low table clubs. these are the player we are targeting, as well as the ones that arent in the plans of top clubs anymore and become opportunities. thats how we always dealt, thats how we will always deal. selling Vidal is irrelevant, as we didnt sell him to fund another transfer (which there is no need to anyway), but we sold him because he asked to leave.
 

Fr3sh

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2011
37,257
They better get themselves a quality player for that position, because if they dont, after selling Vidal, then I'm grabbing my pitchfork out of the garage.
I have extras in case you can't find your pitchfork or if it isn't in good condition (sharp enough).

- - - Updated - - -

. CLUBS WONT SELL THEIR TOP PLAYERS SO EASILY.
lol
 

Dino_mk

Senior Member
Sep 5, 2007
2,053
Wow on the lack of understanding, some members have for the need of buying Mandzukic and Zaza after Dubala purchase.

Do u understand that having only 2 strikers (Dubala and Morata) is suicidal. One injury or drop of form away from playing nonames in the attack or Matri-Bentner-Anelka in winter mercato.

Not to mention availability of loosing Morata next year, for which Juve will be redy, with rest of the attacking players already trained and played for a year.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 42)