imo Final Fantasy : Spirit Within is not a bad movie. it is up to my standard.
The main reason it failed because expectations are too high. they expect the movie to be super super good(10 stars), but it turned out that the movie only get 8 out 10 stars. (imo)
that's why they're dissappointed and start bashing the movie.
another factor is the storyline is a bit complicated, I have to watch the movie twice to understand perfectly the whole story, (the Gaia, the origin of alien,etc...)
so in the end, I think this movie is good. :thumb: