Should Beppe Marotta be sacked? (3 Viewers)

Should Marotta be sacked?

  • Yes - his signings are an embarrassment to the club

  • No - he just got us to the Scudetto and we should see where that takes us

  • WTF - When did we suddenly inherit aching ladyparts like interisti?


Results are only viewable after voting.

WΏΏdy?

Senior Member
Dec 23, 2005
14,997
12 votes each for all three options.

Anyways, i was yelling for morontta's head since last year and as much as i am disgusted but his failure to sign a top WC striker, disgusted but fucking up with the whole berba issue embarassing juventus in the process and of course i think he's a useless little twig, but i dont think we should sack him now and give that position to some caretaker like we did with suckko. If we do have a proven director in sight please fucking fire this clown! PLEASE
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

JuveJay

Senior Signor
Moderator
Mar 6, 2007
74,928
I know we won't fire him, but we should. The guy have no strategy in the market, no negociations skills, can't handle the media..Takes forever to conclude deals, don't have a reputation in Europe.
He came earlier in the summer saying that Juve biggest need is a striker and now he's telling us that we didn't need one :lol:

He's so incompetent and if don't fire him, we'll be ruining a potentially great team with a great coach who can do wonderfull things in Europe with a couple of WC signing, something Beppe can't deliver.
Ruining a great team that he built.

I liked the work Marino did with Napoli. I like their current DS too. I was a big fan of Palermo's Sabatini who is coming into his own at Roma, made some descent signings, but as things stand I think Daniel Prade has shown the most promise this summer.
Seems more like grass is greener syndrome. They might do a better job, but basically there is nothing to actually show that right now. People want a change of transfer scenery, it happens.

How can someone explain to me how he can go and sign Isla for 18 mil and some shit players for as much as 10 and not sign a striker and we end up with freaki,g Bendtner, an Arsenal reject.
No matter how many times you say it Isla did not cost us €18m, he cost €9.4m for a co-ownership. So no, that '€18m' couldn't have been put towards a striker.

Why do we always sound like Marrotta has a list of credits to his name? What were his qualifications before we hired him?? Apart from qualifying for the CL with Sampdoria?? Hiring Daniel Prade, Sabatini is hardly any worse than what we have at this point: a guy who can't sign anybody above 15.5m euros. Or 18, for Matri, was it!?
Can you please state credits for Prade and Sabatini, and why they are not worse.

Yeah, we won the Scudetto, but we did that without a proper goalscoring striker. A top team in any league has a proper striker.
Isn't that contradictory?

And please Nick, stop with BS about how teams aren't willing to sell.

You come with a good offer, teams will listen and eventually will sell in these hard times. Arsenal sold their best player to Man U. Milan sold Zlatan to PSG...

Plenty of good strikers are available, and we end up with freaking Bendtner, The laughing stock of all strikers. Marotta is a fucking disgrace, last year he was running to sign Andreolli on the last day of the transfer and now he signs Bendtner and tell us all how we don't need a striker.

I miss Moggi.
Can I just point out how Van Persie will cost Man Utd £70m over his four year deal; £36m salary, £10m loyalty bonus, £24m transfer fee. That's €88m.

Zlatan will cost PSG €65m over three years.

Martinez, Traore, Rinaudo, Motta, Elia, Pacienza, Ziegler, Padoin...

:howler:
Really.

We didn't even need money from the owners when we had Moggi. Juve was a self sufficient company.
Different club, different league, we are not so fortunate. Moggi played a part in that, too...

I think he's done a good job, but should be replaced by someone more ambitious. I mean, we don't have to fire him at any cost. But should start looking around for someone with more expertise when it comes to dealing with big transactions. Someone who has knowledge of the Italian market but who isn't afraid of taking reasonable risks.
I don't think there is such thing as a 'reasonable risk', it's an oxymoron. You either go with your model and don't budge, or you go high risk high reward and end up with a possibility of being in a poor financial situation.

For all the moaning going on, it needs to be said that we could be in a far worse situation. Exor won't continue to just throw money at a spendthrift club.
 

Suns

Release clause?
May 22, 2009
22,086
I personally think Marotta is great. How can you sack a person who just brought us the scudetto and built us this awesome team because of him not delivering one signing?
 

Bufi

Senior Member
Dec 21, 2010
725
No he shouldn't. He is doing very good job, he his not paying 40m for players who are valuble not more than 15. We have very good team we should take player who can play with heart for us and not for money. We have in every position more than two players, and its very hard to tell who is better and who will be in first 11. I think that is very good, Matri is good golscorer he is not bad, he can play very good in 3-5-2 he need support he can't play in 4-3-3 but in 3-5-2 i think he can be good if he have faith.
 

JuveJay

Senior Signor
Moderator
Mar 6, 2007
74,928
he didn't get us to the scudetto alone, alot was Conte's work and his ability to identify the right players for his system. such as prefering Vidal to Inler.
Obviously. The reasonable thing to say with any Italian teams who succeed is that the credit is split between the coach and sporting director, because that is where the bulk of responsibility lies.
 
May 22, 2007
37,256
That's what I'm discussing as well? Who deserves more credit.
You might have got mixed up in the hatred of this thread, oh well. It's hard to compare because more often than not, coaches will take the most credit when the team is playing well, and then the most blame if a team is performing badly.

Conte is key. No doubt.
 
May 22, 2007
37,256
True and interesting in the same time.

What's the stroy behind Rinaudo, Traore, Motta, Andreolli, Pacienza, Padoin, Bendtner,Borriello......................
I see a lot of players that are average at best, and some that are shite. You're the one dressing up the positive deals to suit your argument, I won't do the same for some of the crap he bought and good he sold.
 

Lion

King of Tuz
Jan 24, 2007
36,185
Lol, he didn't chose Juve over bayer, he was set to join bayern, he had an agreement in place but Bayer $#@!ed him over and refused to sell him.
players are human beings, not robots. he could have just as easily said no juve and leverkusen would halve sold him.

but let's go by your logic for a minute here. we could say that jovetic had an agreement with juventus, and fiorentina fuked him over and refused to sell him, same with dzeko, and llorente. which means marotta has no real power in this case.
 

LowLife

Senior Member
Jan 7, 2011
4,967
Inability to buy a top striker is not the only problem he has. He can't sell for shiit. Melo scored 10 goals (freaking CM) not a striker, and he was suppose to be sold for 12 mil, and he ended up as a loan to Galata. Marotta can't sell a player.
 

napoleonic

Senior Member
Sep 7, 2010
4,129
yes! he could have reasons 1 and 2 seasons again, but not this time... and this time he has been embarrassing himself, the club and the fans by going from targetting WC players to end up with 3rd class rejects or nothing.

no excuse anymore.

can't believe some defend marrotta by conte's work? lol, so if you fucked up in your team job, you should be defended because someone else do the job and saved your ass?
 

GarfielD

Senior Member
May 21, 2009
13,406
Inability to buy a top striker is not the only problem he has. He can't sell for shiit. Melo scored 10 goals (freaking CM) not a striker, and he was suppose to be sold for 12 mil, and he ended up as a loan to Galata. Marotta can't sell a player.
Its not his fault.

For Melo, there was only Gala who had a real interest. Maybe there was some other team, but he wanted Gala and they wanted them. We were desperate to get rid of him, so clearly they had the edge. We are desperate to sell Martinez, IQ, Ziegler etc, but there is not any competition for them, so he will loan them out tomorow by the buyers terms.

Im sure if there is some good and constant first team player that wanted to leave (God forbid), he would sell him for a decent price.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 3)