Randal Kolo Muani - SS/ST - PSG (7 Viewers)

[Mark]

​

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Akshen]

 

[Bianconero_Aus]

The only name that we’re linked too that I kind of like.

There’s a few clubs after him / let’s see if we get him.

 

[DAiDEViL]

Pass

 

[Lion]

Pass

not only he sucks, but he is also ugly. so not even good eye candy

 

[Alex-444]

 

[X Æ A-12]

not only he sucks, but he is also ugly. so not even good eye candy

Also his name is Randy lol

 

[Dostoevsky]

So what are the other options?

 

[Lion]

Also his name is Randy lol

how did a black man get a redneck name? was he adopted

 

[s4tch]

he has 2 goals this season? savona replacement then?

 

[Rockets]

Can he bury sitters?

 

[s4tch]

Can he bury sitters?

2 goals from 4+ xg, what does it tell you

seriously, what's wrong with this club. injured, injury prone players are welcome, but strikers that actually score aren't even considered lol

 

[Alin]

2 goals from 4+ xg, what does it tell you

seriously, what's wrong with this club. injured, injury prone players are welcome, but strikers that actually score aren't even considered lol

The primary requirement of our transfer targets seems to be for them to be market opportunities or transfer listed by other clubs, then if they are also injury prone it’s almost guaranteed that we’ll be interested, only after that we evaluate if he is really worth it or if he has the characteristics that we need to actually improve the squad and fill the gaps…

- - - Updated - - -

And i’m rather fine with getting Kolo as backup/depth, but only if we keep Vlahovic for now too, guy is versatile and has lots of pace which can help us cover on the wings too, but sure isn’t the guy to lead the line as of yet.

 

[Zzak]

One hit wonder for Frankfurt. Clearly past his peak.
It would be Zirkzee or pass for me.

 

[Alin]

One hit wonder for Frankfurt. Clearly past his peak.
It would be Zirkzee or pass for me.

There are many question marks no doubt, but clearly past his peak is a stretch, in fact he is closer to enter his prime years if anything…

By the same logic, as things stand isn’t Zirkzee also pretty much a one hit wonder for Bologna too?

 

[Zzak]

There are many question marks no doubt, but clearly past his peak is a stretch, in fact he is closer to enter his prime years if anything…

By the same logic, as things stand isn’t Zirkzee also pretty much a one hit wonder for Bologna too?

- He's left the team where he shinned just 6 months ago compared to the 18 months of Muani
- He's 2 years younger
- He would play in the same championship where he shinned last season under the same coach, with arguably better team mates.


- Muani never played in Serie A. He was good only in the german farmer's league. He failed in the French farmer's league while playing for PSG as their sole striker. Basically every striker's wet dream. Even Moise Kean had better numbers there.

 

[Alin]

- He's left the team where he shinned just 6 months ago compared to the 18 months of Muani
- He's 2 years younger
- He would play in the same championship where he shinned last season under the same coach, with arguably better team mates.


- Muani never played in Serie A. He was good only in the german farmer's league. He failed in the French farmer's league while playing for PSG as their sole striker. Basically every striker's wet dream. Even Moise Kean had better numbers there.

Good arguments, and i agree with most of them, just that the ‘one hit wonder’ description still fits both as it stands, but as you mentioned the biggest advantage when comparing the two is that Zirkzee knows the league already and more so the coach.

- - - Updated - - -

Regarding Kolo Muani’s stint at PSG i’d suggest we should look at it also from the perspective of them as a club being an overall mess lately with issues behind the scenes and Luis Enrique preferring to play with a false 9 too, which is why i wouldn’t say he is finished or past his peak as of yet.

 

[da_ledgeaun]

Zirkzee over Randal for me

 

[JuveJay]

Have a bad feeling about Random Mofo. Hopefully he's a new Marcus Thuram.

 

[Osman]

Have a bad feeling about Random Mofo. Hopefully he's a new Marcus Thuram.

He really isn't. Thuram is very dynamic and direct, you could see him grow into a goal threat from just a winger into CF through the years.

While Muani is all around useful type, but rarely ever looked like a threat whenever you seen him for France or club. More of a mobile complimentary role player then main goal contributing (goals or assists(.



I doubt it, but I hope he cultivate scoring touch with us. And hope it's only loan.


P.S in Frankfurt years both Kostic and Lindstrom looked better then him, and now they in Turkish league or Everton bench.