Paulo Dybala (171 Viewers)

Legend or Rookie? ***non-official poll***

  • Total voters
    140
  • Poll closed .

pitbull

Senior Member
#10,261
Jul 26, 2007
11,045
#10,261
Osman said:
They ofcourse make a difference, all players on the pitch does. But I mean in comparison with the other positions.

When it comes to goalies, Barca issue isnt Ter Stegen even if he isnt a top player, but everything in defence and midfield. Besides what Ocelot said, I will illustrate the biggiest argument against what you just said, here:

I give you the starting goalies for the two sides that been the most successful era teams in past 30 years (and in football history in general).




Click to expand...
Valdez was a good keeper, that Barca had some more questionable outfield players like Eidur Gudjohnsen, Seydou Keita, Sylvinho or Alexander Hleb (ok, this guy was not a starter, but had to throw him in :D). About Rossi no idea honestly, started following footie in the early 00's, was he that bad?

Buffon had a big impact on Italy winning 2006, probably bigger than Totti, Del Piero, Camoranesi or other stars of Italy. Kahn in 2002 had a huge impact on Germany going to the finals, where he once again had a huge impact in them losing to Brazil. For me goalkeeper is the most essential part of the defense, more important than the CB's and fullbacks. Let me put it this way, if I am a CB in a 4 man defense, I'd rather have a shitty CB partner me than a shitty goalie behind me.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com
Bianconero_Aus

Bianconero_Aus

Beppe Marotta Is My God
#10,262
May 26, 2009
80,943
#10,262
I take Osman's point, but Seba Rossi was pretty underrated. Not a fantastic keeper by any stretch, but was pretty solid and dependable for the most part and was around at a time when Italy had amazing depth in GK stocks (Zenga, Tacconi, Pagliuca, Marchegianni, Bucci etc) and couldn't get a sniff at the time.
 

Zacheryah

Senior Member
#10,263
Aug 29, 2010
42,251
#10,263
pitbull said:
Valdez was a good keeper, that Barca had some more questionable outfield players like Eidur Gudjohnsen, Seydou Keita, Sylvinho or Alexander Hleb (ok, this guy was not a starter, but had to throw him in :D). About Rossi no idea honestly, started following footie in the early 00's, was he that bad?

Buffon had a big impact on Italy winning 2006, probably bigger than Totti, Del Piero, Camoranesi or other stars of Italy. Kahn in 2002 had a huge impact on Germany going to the finals, where he once again had a huge impact in them losing to Brazil. For me goalkeeper is the most essential part of the defense, more important than the CB's and fullbacks. Let me put it this way, if I am a CB in a 4 man defense, I'd rather have a shitty CB partner me than a shitty goalie behind me.
Click to expand...
Certainly with the amount of distance shooters these days
 
Osman

Osman

Koul Khara!
#10,267
Aug 30, 2002
61,489
#10,267
Um he had a fantastic 2nd half. He was not a factor first half because they had extremely tight man marking on him centrally, Masiello followed him everywhere, unnerved him, missed passes etc. Couple that with aggressive pressure and tackling, our approaches down the middle was a kill zone (more harder when ref allowed hard fouls from the back with no yellows).


That's why it was ingenious 2nd half for him, wether he came up with it or was Allegri direction, he was smart enough to realize he needs to get out of pocket, essentially played as 2nd RW, moving centrally when their initial pressure subsided, then drifted wide again, impossible to mark and was involved with all open play actions we had in 2nd half.

Skickat från min SM-G930F via Tapatalk
 
DUKAC

DUKAC

Senior Member
#10,270
Feb 29, 2012
12,286
#10,270
Kopanja said:
Have you watched the second half at all? He was one of the best after Alves and Pjanic.
Click to expand...
Watched and recorded the game like all our games. Second half.... "He was best after Alves and Pjanic".... .Not a fierce competition to be the third best player when all the players were bad.He had many,many better displays.This one wasn't his best display ,to be generous saying.And also,our whole team was better in the second half.He is a phenomenon and he should make the difference when the rest of our squad are playing poorly.
 
DUKAC

DUKAC

Senior Member
#10,276
Feb 29, 2012
12,286
#10,276
juventus4life said:
The whole team didn't care for the game. Why always bitch and moan?
Click to expand...
Read something before you quote.I wrote that the whole team plays badly and that he is the player who can make the difference in that circumstances.Why always hail and glorify when there is no room for that?Be realistic.Always hailing our players no matter what they do doesn't help Juve or yourself, to pretend that you are a big Juve fan.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 3, Guests: 146)