Paulo Dybala (169 Viewers)

Legend or Rookie? ***non-official poll***


  • Total voters
    140
  • Poll closed .

Vlad

In Allegri We Trust
May 23, 2011
24,028
It wasn't tied with Boksic. Del Piero outscored Vieri across competitions. 15 goals to 14 goals. Boksic? He had like 3 goals in Serie A that year. :lol:

We have never just sold players because they asked to leave or because of big offers.

Every single example of a sale of a big player, has clear implications of the club moving on from players.

Inzaghi... we had bought Trez the year before and decided to move forward with him.

Vieri... we had for one year, just like every single club he played for before Inter. We didn't see him as integral to the team and replaced him with Inzaghi.

Baggio... Our management disliked him, we had an upcoming superstar no 10 in Del Piero, and the club decided to go in that direction which was clearly the right decision.

Zidane was coming off his worst couple seasons at Juventus. Including a really disappointing last season. He wanted to move, and the club had no desire to keep him as we needed to rebuild as well. He was also 29.

Vidal was coming off his worst season, with huge disciplinary problems, and alcohol problems.

None of these were just an under-25 player demanding to be sold, or the club accepting big offers for our under-25 superstars.

We've never done that. Ever.

- - - Updated - - -



:agree:
spot on
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

baggio

Senior Member
Jun 3, 2003
19,250
Vieri scored 8 goals in Serie A and you call it a good season. We sold the guy who didn't deliver and replaced him with the top Serie A scorer of the previous season. Inzaghi.
It was a good season because he was top scorer with Ale in Serie a at 8 goals, and I think it was him and Boksic tied in Europe as top scorers in that season. Overall, that same season Vieri was top scorer with Ale across competitions, give or take a goal.


Baggio was benched for Ale for most of the year and this is also the case of a player near his 30s, where it's wiser to sell before too late. Neither at Milan or Inter did he rediscover his previous form on a regular basis.
Baggio was benched also coz of the politics between him Lippi and Moggi. They wanted him to take a huge paycut and that triggered his sale in a primary way. He actually didn't do too bad for Meelan, coz the year we sold him he got injured but recovered well with a few goals and a high assist ratio that eventually helped them win the the Scudetto that year. If you remember, Lippi and Baggio never saw eye to eye and that fractious relationship was well documented at Inter too.


Trez and Inzagi were both top forwards but they would never have been satisfied to share playing time. Trez was obviously more talented and had more facets to his game. Simple decision of upgrading the attack as proven in subsequent years when Trez outscored Inzaghi in almost every season.
I'm a huge fan of Trez, and I had a distinct dislike for Pippo, but we are saying this in hindsight. There's nothing to suggest that Pippo wouldn't have continued to deliver had he stayed. It worked out great for everyone involved, but that alludes to my point that we arent afraid to sell.


Definitely looked past it in his final year here.
Honestly bud, which player doesn't have an off season or so!? Nedved started with a below par year but look how that ended up for him. Form is temporary, class is permanent. Zizou isn't the player you sell because of a dip in form. Thats like saying we would sell Pogba if he had an off season. We sold Zizou coz he wanted out. More his wife, but still that was the primary reason. As was the case with Vidal.
 

Post Ironic

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2013
42,253
@baggio

Sorry if I went a little ad hominem on you there. I think we're mostly in agreement. The club isn't afraid to sell, but pretty much always on its own terms, and has never really sold under-25 stars. I'm curious to see how the next couple years play out.
 

Vlad

In Allegri We Trust
May 23, 2011
24,028
It was a good season because he was top scorer with Ale in Serie a at 8 goals, and I think it was him and Boksic tied in Europe as top scorers in that season. Overall, that same season Vieri was top scorer with Ale across competitions, give or take a goal.
DP was injured most of the season so this isn't some teriffic accomplishment, that he was tied with a player, who missed half the games that year.



Baggio was benched also coz of the politics between him Lippi and Moggi. They wanted him to take a huge paycut and that triggered his sale in a primary way. He actually didn't do too bad for Meelan, coz the year we sold him he got injured but recovered well with a few goals and a high assist ratio that eventually helped them win the the Scudetto that year. If you remember, Lippi and Baggio never saw eye to eye and that fractious relationship was well documented at Inter too.
Because he wasnt considered indispensable anymore with young and up and coming DP. Ofc we're looking to reduce the salary for those kind of players. That should be enough to tell you how the club had felt about Baggio in his final year.



I'm a huge fan of Trez, and I had a distinct dislike for Pippo, but we are saying this in hindsight. There's nothing to suggest that Pippo wouldn't have continued to deliver had he stayed. It worked out great for everyone involved, but that alludes to my point that we arent afraid to sell.
His last year here was exactly what suggested that he won't deliver anymore. And Trez outscored him that year so this wasn't tough decision nor do we need hindsight to evaluate mgt's choice. You have younger, more prolific striker, with more aspects to his game and on the other side there's a guy who may consider himself the luckiest foward that has ever played footie. No skills, poor shot, but fantastic positioning. Both want a starting place. I know who I'd choose.



Honestly bud, which player doesn't have an off year!? Nedved started with a below par year but look how that ended up for him. Form is temporary, class is permanent. Zizou isn't the player you sell because of a dip in form. Thats like saying we would sell Pogba if he had an off season. We sold Zizou coz he wanted out. More his wife, but still that was the primary reason. As was the case with Vidal.
It wasn't dip in form. Zidane didn't perform for us anymore nowhere close to the level he had been between 96-99. For 71m, record fee at that time, it's a no brainer.

The whole point is that neither player that we have sold over the years wasnt in prime of their abilities, that either lost his place to younger competitor (Baggio, Inzaghi), struggled to get to previous levels (Zidane) or have off the field issues (Vidal).
 

baggio

Senior Member
Jun 3, 2003
19,250
@baggio

Sorry if I went a little ad hominem on you there. I think we're mostly in agreement. The club isn't afraid to sell, but pretty much always on its own terms, and has never really sold under-25 stars. I'm curious to see how the next couple years play out.
Not at all bud. Had a bit of a rough day so I probably came off a little unstuck myself. Apologies.
 

baggio

Senior Member
Jun 3, 2003
19,250
DP was injured most of the season so this isn't some teriffic accomplishment, that he was tied with a player, who missed half the games that year.



Because he wasnt considered indispensable anymore with young and up and coming DP. Ofc we're looking to reduce the salary for those kind of players. That should be enough to tell you how the club had felt about Baggio in his final year.



His last year here was exactly what suggested that he won't deliver anymore. And Trez outscored him that year so this wasn't tough decision nor do we need hindsight to evaluate mgt's choice. You have younger, more prolific striker, with more aspects to his game and on the other side there's a guy who may consider himself the luckiest foward that has ever played footie. No skills, poor shot, but fantastic positioning. Both want a starting place. I know who I'd choose.



It wasn't dip in form. Zidane didn't perform for us anymore nowhere close to the level he had been between 96-99. For 71m, record fee at that time, it's a no brainer.

The whole point is that neither player that we have sold over the years wasnt in prime of their abilities, that either lost his place to younger competitor (Baggio, Inzaghi), struggled to get to previous levels (Zidane) or have off the field issues (Vidal).
Please don't take this the wrong way, but I've already made my points on this matter and don't want to discuss it any further coz it's going around in circles. No offense, just had a bit of a long day. Peace. :tup:

- - - Updated - - -

Whats with the appologies everyone :D
I think the mutual respect between the old guard at the Tuz kind of kicks in every now and then. You will learn young Zizinho.
 

zizinho

Senior Member
Apr 14, 2013
51,816
Please don't take this the wrong way, but I've already made my points on this matter and don't want to discuss it any further coz it's going around in circles. No offense, just had a bit of a long day. Peace. :tup:

- - - Updated - - -



I think the mutual respect between the old guard at the Tuz kind of kicks in every now and then. You will learn young Zizinho.
This is a site where people talk shit and insult each other all the time, i dont think you have to appologize for being a bit harsh. But oh well
 

Valerio.

Senior Member
Jul 5, 2014
5,762
DP was injured most of the season so this isn't some teriffic accomplishment, that he was tied with a player, who missed half the games that year.



Because he wasnt considered indispensable anymore with young and up and coming DP. Ofc we're looking to reduce the salary for those kind of players. That should be enough to tell you how the club had felt about Baggio in his final year.



His last year here was exactly what suggested that he won't deliver anymore. And Trez outscored him that year so this wasn't tough decision nor do we need hindsight to evaluate mgt's choice. You have younger, more prolific striker, with more aspects to his game and on the other side there's a guy who may consider himself the luckiest foward that has ever played footie. No skills, poor shot, but fantastic positioning. Both want a starting place. I know who I'd choose.



It wasn't dip in form. Zidane didn't perform for us anymore nowhere close to the level he had been between 96-99. For 71m, record fee at that time, it's a no brainer.

The whole point is that neither player that we have sold over the years wasnt in prime of their abilities, that either lost his place to younger competitor (Baggio, Inzaghi), struggled to get to previous levels (Zidane) or have off the field issues (Vidal).
Dude are you high?!?
Zidane was no where what??!? what the heck did he do for 5 years in Real Madrid becoming of their legends???
 

baggio

Senior Member
Jun 3, 2003
19,250
This is a site where people talk shit and insult each other all the time, i dont think you have to appologize for being a bit harsh. But oh well
Na. You'll notice some understand how to address others. I've been around here a long time, and a lot of my approach today with fellow posters is about respecting their opinions no matter how much shit someone may spew or how much of a disagreement there maybe. I guess it's a generational thing on the Tuz. Back in the day, half of the convos you see on here today wouldn't even exist. It's degenerate how some people approach convos here today, but you gotta live with it and work around it.
 

zizinho

Senior Member
Apr 14, 2013
51,816
Na. You'll notice some understand how to address others. I've been around here a long time, and a lot of my approach today with fellow posters is about respecting their opinions no matter how much shit someone may spew or how much of a disagreement there maybe. I guess it's a generational thing on the Tuz. Back in the day, half of the convos you see on here today wouldn't even exist. It's degenerate how some people approach convos here today, but you gotta live with it and work around it.
OK, sorry for bothering you then
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 141)