Paulo Dybala (186 Viewers)

Legend or Rookie? ***non-official poll***


  • Total voters
    140
  • Poll closed .

DUKAC

Senior Member
Feb 29, 2012
12,286
And where is dybala gonna play in Barca? He sure ain't benching Suarez and Messi. What kind of formations does Valverde usually play? If Barca does splash the cash for Dybala I think the only winner there will be Juve, Dybala and Barca will be losers. It's mot a good replacement for Neymar and you know that will have to pay us a huge amount 100m+. We will recover, but Dybala won't fit perfectly and Barca will be 100m short.
Why you are interested where he would play there when he will leave Juve?
 
OP
Dostoevsky

Dostoevsky

Tzu
Administrator
May 27, 2007
88,988
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #11,487
    Define attractive club my friend.

    Today they are only money wise ahead of Juve but don't know if it falls under attraction phrase though.
    A club that can give high wages (higher than ours), club that has almost double our revenues, club that has one of the best players in the world in their squad, players that they keep and usually reject all of the bids unless some crazy club triggers a release clause.

    If players dream about joining an elite club they surely think of either Real or Barcelona. Just because we reached 2 CL finals in 3 years doesn't necessarily mean that we're the best club in the world, because, imo, we're far away from that. Although, I gotta admit, we're on a good road (bar this transfer mercato which is getting me worried).

    After Juve there's actually another step forward in the future and it's joining clubs like Real. If you think we're at that level then I have nothing else to add.

    Obviously papers gonna be filled with such rumours but how does it make the Dybala sale more probable? They will mention as many names as they can. You act like Juve have no saying in Dybs sale which is illogical. You may use Pogba as a precedent but every case is different. You make Juventus look like total retards that do not adjust to the changing surrounding. I will not explain why we sold Bonu and Pogba again because you know the reasons. All I'm gonna say is each of Bonu, Pogba and Dybala cases is totally different.

    Wysłane z mojego FRD-L09 przy użyciu Tapatalka
    You're right about all of that. But is it possible to lose Dybala? It surely is. Will he stay here next season? Maybe. Will he be here in 5 years? No, he won't. Because, as it stands, it's just a matter of time before we finalize his sale. Like PI mentioned, it usually takes 3-4 seasons, while Dybala has been here for only two. Even if we manage to keep and even if we rejected bids for him (which we did) it doesn't mean he's here to retire.
     

    Gigiventus

    Senior Member
    Mar 3, 2017
    3,276
    Why you are interested where he would play there when he will leave Juve?
    Because if there is no room for a 100m starter, then the transfer isn't happening. They would be really dumb (as we know them to be sometimes) to break the bank like that for a player that has to start, but doesn't fit.
     
    OP
    Dostoevsky

    Dostoevsky

    Tzu
    Administrator
    May 27, 2007
    88,988
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #11,490
    I can't belive some pf you think we have a chance to sign Verratti . :lol:


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
    And I can't believe people are thinking we're the best club in the world that can reject crazy bids just because.

    You know what will happen if Barca signs Dybala? People will be saying exactly this: we accepted because the bid is way too high, Barca sold Neymar for 222mln, this happens once in a blue moon otherwise we wouldn't have sold him.

    Excuses for our sales will just pile up.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Because if there is no room for a 100m starter, then the transfer isn't happening. They would be really dumb (as we know them to be sometimes) to break the bank like that for a player that has to start, but doesn't fit.
    IMO he actually fits Barca and I think he'd be very good there.

    But hey, you never know. Costa might not fit here, Berna might not fit. It's always a gamble. They fucked up with Ibra but they nailed quite a few transfers.
     

    JuveJay

    Senior Signor
    Moderator
    Mar 6, 2007
    74,909
    You know what will happen if Barca signs Dybala? People will be saying exactly this: we accepted because the bid is way too high, Barca sold Neymar for 222mln, this happens once in a blue moon otherwise we wouldn't have sold him.

    Excuses for our sales will just pile up.
    You know that it would be true, or else you wouldn't have pre-empted it. If Barfa do offer something silly then it is because they sold Neymar for an astronomical fee.

    Could be that Barfa were in a financial position to offer a massive fee anyway, but the requirement for a replacement is the bigger incentive. For me Dybala still doesn't make any sense whilst Messi is there.
     

    Albo

    Senior Member
    Apr 13, 2009
    11,463
    And I can't believe people are thinking we're the best club in the world that can reject crazy bids just because.

    You know what will happen if Barca signs Dybala? People will be saying exactly this: we accepted because the bid is way too high, Barca sold Neymar for 222mln, this happens once in a blue moon otherwise we wouldn't have sold him.

    Excuses for our sales will just pile up.

    - - - Updated - - -



    IMO he actually fits Barca and I think he'd be very good there.

    But hey, you never know. Costa might not fit here, Berna might not fit. It's always a gamble. They fucked up with Ibra but they nailed quite a few transfers.
    I thnik everyone knows we're not best club , yeah we did great past 3 years , we overshadowed Barca,Bayern and all other clubs except fucking Madrid , but they still better .

    I think it doesn't matter if we (forum) justify his sale , personally I wouldn't sell , but ffs if we sell please let it be at least 150m+ , yes he isn't worth it , but they gona be desperate to replace Neymar and they gona pay , but as I said I'm against his sale , but I'm afraid we gona sell him for 100m + 4.7m bonuses :mad:

    Dybala 99% would do great for Barca , it it's gona be huge blow for our squad, we finally have extremely creative attack , one of the best in the world ,only Real,Barca have better strikers .


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     

    Azzurri7

    Pinturicchio
    Moderator
    Dec 16, 2003
    72,692
    A club that can give high wages (higher than ours), club that has almost double our revenues, club that has one of the best players in the world in their squad, players that they keep and usually reject all of the bids unless some crazy club triggers a release clause.

    If players dream about joining an elite club they surely think of either Real or Barcelona. Just because we reached 2 CL finals in 3 years doesn't necessarily mean that we're the best club in the world, because, imo, we're far away from that. Although, I gotta admit, we're on a good road (bar this transfer mercato which is getting me worried).

    After Juve there's actually another step forward in the future and it's joining clubs like Real. If you think we're at that level then I have nothing else to add.
    Money wise they are ahead obviously and for obvious reasons and that is mainly the biggest reason why players want to play for Barcelona and not Juve for instance. Second reason is mainly because their fan-base has increased worldwide in the last 7-8 years, before that they were no where up to Juve's.

    Players want to play with the best players? Of course, but apart from Messi, we are pretty much ahead of them in terms of player's qualities.

    Another good reason is because Serie a quality has fell. Once serie a is back, Juve will be among three clubs in the world like it has always been the case.
     

    GiocataGrande

    Commendatore
    May 26, 2016
    4,073
    He can leave, but I want CASH to be dropped bigtime!!! dont give him away easily. If we bend over like with Vidal again it would be a real shame to our club. Show some balls and stand your ground for once.

    - - - Updated - - -

    And the people thinking about Veratti : forget it! We cant even sign Matuidi, matic or Nzonzi, Hell even Cancelo. What makes you think we have a chance for Veratti?
     

    Zacheryah

    Senior Member
    Aug 29, 2010
    42,251
    He can leave, but I want CASH to be dropped bigtime!!! dont give him away easily. If we bend over like with Vidal again it would be a real shame to our club. Show some balls and stand your ground for once.

    - - - Updated - - -

    And the people thinking about Veratti : forget it! We cant even sign Matuidi, matic or Nzonzi, Hell even Cancelo. What makes you think we have a chance for Veratti?
    Its too late. We should say "preseason started, gtfo. Have him next summer"
     

    DUKAC

    Senior Member
    Feb 29, 2012
    12,286
    Because if there is no room for a 100m starter, then the transfer isn't happening. They would be really dumb (as we know them to be sometimes) to break the bank like that for a player that has to start, but doesn't fit.
    What are you posting has nothing to do with the fact that he is gone once Barcelona decide to knock our door for him.And it won't be more than 120,maybe less millions.
     
    OP
    Dostoevsky

    Dostoevsky

    Tzu
    Administrator
    May 27, 2007
    88,988
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #11,499
    Money wise they are ahead obviously and for obvious reasons and that is mainly the biggest reason why players want to play for Barcelona and not Juve for instance. Second reason is mainly because their fan-base has increased worldwide in the last 7-8 years, before that they were no where up to Juve's.

    Players want to play with the best players? Of course, but apart from Messi, we are pretty much ahead of them in terms of player's qualities.
    Suarez? Iniesta? Alba? Mascherano? Rakitic etc. They also have some good young players like Umtiti and Vidal.

    You're right, though, money wise. But it's that money that brings you quality. It's just that Real Madrid does it a lot better than Barca.

    Let me ask you something. Answer me honestly. Do you think an attractive club/elite club would end up buying D.Costa, Bernardeschi and De Sciglio? And selling Bonucci while not even replacing him. Because, imo, a top club would never buy such players.

    I'm not saying we're signing shit players, but we're obviously not even competiting to buy top players simply because we cannot do that. Yes, one may say that we bought Pipita, but come on, we spent so much just because we sold Pogba. Just like we're gonna spend so much IF we sell Dybala eventually.

    Look at our recent moves. Tevez, Vidal, Pirlo, Barzagli, Morata, Rugani, Caldara, Dybala, Pogba, etc. You see the pattern? It's players that needed to revive their career and young players with potential that we could place our hands on using the opportunity/Raiola. We ended up shaping Pogba & Morata and shipping them off. We did the same with Vidal. We're doing it with Dybala now.

    We are a great club and in the top 10 in the world. No doubt about that. But we can't compete with the top clubs when it comes to players. That's why we never chase Neymar, James Rodriguez, Suarez, Jesus and others. It's money that gets them and money is coming from Spanish clubs, Bayern and some Arabs.

    I might be wrong but I think once player has taken its shape I think they dream about Real and Barca. I also think playing at Camp Nou that's always filled is a big deal for them. And it's not just Barca per se, but Spain, and La Liga. I think their league is far more attractive than Serie A. In Spain you compete with Real Madrid, the best club in world, and you get to play alongside Messi. It's a big deal. In Italy you get to play infront of 30% crowd in the empty stadiums, horrible stadiums and without any tough competition. Napoli is strong but they spend peanuts. Roma was strong yet they sold everyone. It's just us. Once you reach a certain level I think players desire to leave the club, just like it happened with Vidal, Pogba and others. And mark my words. It's going to happen with both Dybala and Sandro. It's just a matter of time. It might be next summer, or 2-3 years. But they will leave us for top clubs.
     

    Gigiventus

    Senior Member
    Mar 3, 2017
    3,276
    What are you posting has nothing to do with the fact that he is gone once Barcelona decide to knock our door for him.And it won't be more than 120,maybe less millions.
    You need to work on your reading comprehension. Of course it's relevant. But that's besides the point. The point is about whether Barca would be willing to drop your 120m on him in the first place.
     

    Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 164)