Dybala should stay.. if we have to offload a striker, it's higuain that should go
After seeing the way Higgy's conducting himself this preseason I'm beginning to question that. I love Mandzukic for all the obvious reasons but his style as CF wouldn't fit Sarri's football IMO. Sarri needs a quick and tricky false 9 or a CF that can be played off - playing with the back to goal, providing the right passes.
Mandzukic surprisingly does not provide that at CF. He is a pretty lousy CF for this team actually. He doesn't have pace, he doesn't contribute to hold up play as you think a striker of his size and strength would. He requires a centimeter-perfect cross to get a look in at goal. When he was a hybrid-winger he made up for his lack of pace because he could track back a lot more and play as an extra defensive-mid. He could also creep in at the far post and snag goals that way - Higuain would draw defenders and all Mandzukic had to do was jump over or sneak behind a full-back.
Sarri is never going to use Mandzukic as a winger and he just lacks dynamism at CF. He's getting slow, predictable and easy to mark.
Dybala can really excel as a false 9 under Sarri because he understands the role. False 9s just weren't Allegri's thing. But Dybala at his best is IMO a better option than Eriksen and yes, even Neymar given all the negatives associated with him. I would 100% swap him for Pogba though.