Many players chocked because of the tactics, and the position they played. If the coach tells you to stay behind all the time, and shoot the ball towards Toni when they have it, even if it is in their own side, then not even Maradona could do anything with this team and tactics. If you play with 4 defenders, and 3 or even 4 defensive midfielders, and one striker front and alone, who could do anything?
They played it for penalties, like Italy is penalty experts, like Buffon is a penalty expert.