++ [ originally posted by Shadowfax ] ++
Thats exactly what i wanted andy, different views on what makes a glory hunter are interesting...
Couple of comments...
You say "while in reality he doesnt"... How do you know... what draws you to that conclusion...
What I mean in reality is the fan does not really care about the club unless it's winning, therefore he doesn't actually care for the club. This also has to do with not caring about the traditions of the club, etc.
Where is your limit on switching alliances... Eg. a child brought up being taken to the club of their father every week... Is that person a glory hunter when they make their own choice and switch teams ?
Maybe a teenager switchs alliances throughout his childhood but stays with their final choice forever... is that a glory hunter ?
It depends really. If the first child grew up attending Hellas matches with his father and then decided to switch to Inter during adulthood that could be considered a case of glory hunting. If a child keep switching clubs during childhood he probably doesn't have any father figure directing him to any club, so it is up to his own discretion...if continues to switch clubs when he is more mature I would certainly question it.
Biggest case of gloryhunting would be following Juventus up to 2003 then switching to Milan just cuz they won the CL...that is pathetic.
you say he only likes ateam because they win, but then when did you start supporting juve, was it during a slum or a successful period ? if the latter, is that not the same ?
I first started to like Juve in 1998 after I watched the CL Final with Real Madrid....that was the first European club match I ever saw. I loved watching Zidane in that specifc match and because I did not really know much about club football from 98 until 2000 Juventus just stuck with me as the team I first saw. I did not become a hardcore fan until about 2000 and for some reason I became even more of a fan when we lost Zidane, my favorite absolute player.
As for Juve successes in that period...I'm sure you know Paul. When we lost Zidane I thought the world was going to end.
Surely you can only really tell a glory hunter by their reaction when the club is suffering... Something i believe most here have never experienced... so can you be sure ?
Interesting...your probably right. The real supporters will stick with their club through thick and thin, and it would be a true test for Juventini if Juventus indeed go through a bad spell. If worse comes to worst and the Elkann brothers somehow fail to keep the club successful after the Triade leaves office, we could see an unsuccessful era ahead of us....anything is possible.
I recall a lot of Samp supporters discussing their feelings after their Era "D'Oro" ended in the 90's and how they have stuck with their club all the way to this day...inspiring stuff I suppose.