'Murica! (153 Viewers)

ALC

Ohaulick
Oct 28, 2010
46,535
after all it's a chinese spy software, isn't it. it asks for permission to access basically every data on your phone and no one can control what happens with that data
That’s not how it really works. I don’t let it access my photos or microphone, and it won’t be able to access stuff like passwords, etc. the data it’s stealing is more like your browsing data, the same stuff Facebook, instagram, etal already do. The fake outrage is because it’s Chinese and not American spying.

- - - Updated - - -

Any way this changes with Trump? Or he's the one pushing for this
I don’t see Trump being particularly easy on China and he’ll probably get told by Elon Musk what to do, which is to force a sale to Elon himself.
 
Jun 16, 2020
12,435
after all it's a chinese spy software, isn't it. it asks for permission to access basically every data on your phone and no one can control what happens with that data
This plus when I learned that the algoritm for Chinese kids in China versus the West is totally different I started to mistrust them.

https://www.deseret.com/2022/11/24/23467181/difference-between-tik-tok-in-china-and-the-us/

For some time ive been thinking that the trans movement with kids involved is partially because they got exposed to it on TikTok. Seems like a rational thing to do if youre China.
 

icemaη

Rab's Husband - The Regista
Moderator
Aug 27, 2008
36,357
I didn’t know Tiktok is banned in India too
We banned a bunch of Chinese apps including AliExpress and Shein. It was the time they encroached into Indian territory and stole land I think. It was mostly performative though, considering China is still one of India’s top trade partner.
Indian TikTok was bonkers though. There was nothing like it. Creators from tier 2 and tier 3 cities were making good money in a way they couldn’t on a polished platform like Instagram. It was raw and real and entertaining in a way that was never really recreated after.
 

icemaη

Rab's Husband - The Regista
Moderator
Aug 27, 2008
36,357
This plus when I learned that the algoritm for Chinese kids in China versus the West is totally different I started to mistrust them.

https://www.deseret.com/2022/11/24/23467181/difference-between-tik-tok-in-china-and-the-us/

For some time ive been thinking that the trans movement with kids involved is partially because they got exposed to it on TikTok. Seems like a rational thing to do if youre China.
It has to do with what China allows vs what the US allows. Every platform in the US makes their algorithm addictive. The reasons TikTok gets flak on this is because it’s Chinese and more importantly, their algorithms are damn good in a way that none of the US based social media platforms are able to recreate.
I’m not discounting that TikTok gathers a metric ton of data (which is what makes the algorithm great) or that China is not doing something nefarious btw. But banning a platform seems like an over reach to me. Especially if you are doing it under the guise of national security.
 

Siamak

╭∩╮( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)╭∩╮
Aug 13, 2013
18,430
I don't use this shit Tiktok because I feel it suits for stupid teenagers but some people are addicted to it. Would be nice if they could take it down for good.
 

Siamak

╭∩╮( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)╭∩╮
Aug 13, 2013
18,430
This plus when I learned that the algoritm for Chinese kids in China versus the West is totally different I started to mistrust them.

https://www.deseret.com/2022/11/24/23467181/difference-between-tik-tok-in-china-and-the-us/

For some time ive been thinking that the trans movement with kids involved is partially because they got exposed to it on TikTok. Seems like a rational thing to do if youre China.
bullshit! the large amount of pornographic content on X seems to be even more terrible.

- - - Updated - - -

You mean eliminate all those stupid teenagers? You might be on to something here.
No, all those nonsense social media apps, your average IQ will rise 20 points within a day.
 

s4tch

Senior Member
Mar 23, 2015
33,663
It has to do with what China allows vs what the US allows. Every platform in the US makes their algorithm addictive. The reasons TikTok gets flak on this is because it’s Chinese and more importantly, their algorithms are damn good in a way that none of the US based social media platforms are able to recreate.
I’m not discounting that TikTok gathers a metric ton of data (which is what makes the algorithm great) or that China is not doing something nefarious btw. But banning a platform seems like an over reach to me. Especially if you are doing it under the guise of national security.
the point of the article what @U Picciriddu posted is a bit more nuanced though. it's not about making the content addictive. scrolling, interacting IS addictive on its own. the big difference is that in china they show your kids some scientific stuff, creative, educational, and of course patriotic content. everywhere else (not only in the us) it's the junk time wasting stuff

as for "every app collects everything" argument, even if there's no difference between the apps (and there is, at least there was a few years ago when i read tiktok's terms and conditions and blocked that shit in my firewall), as a murican citizen, would you want usa based companies to handle your data, or the chinese communist party? same goes for europeans or any other nation. personally i'd rather give my burner card data to amazon/google instead of aliexpress/wechat and i also stopped buying chinese smart devices a few years ago. there are just way too many question marks about them and i don't want to waste my time with investigating the very device before buying, be it a phone or a vacuum cleaner lol: https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2024/10/robot-vacuum-cleaners-hacked-to-spy-on-insult-owners

bottom line is that it's a war. bans for huawei, zte and tiktok are part of it. whether the ban is fair or not doesn't matter. too bad murica (and europe) are already screwed in way too many fields. they shouldn't have let china manufacture everything, yet they are doing exactly this, from electronics to industrial materials like epoxy
 
Jun 16, 2020
12,435
the point of the article what @U Picciriddu posted is a bit more nuanced though. it's not about making the content addictive. scrolling, interacting IS addictive on its own. the big difference is that in china they show your kids some scientific stuff, creative, educational, and of course patriotic content. everywhere else (not only in the us) it's the junk time wasting stuff

as for "every app collects everything" argument, even if there's no difference between the apps (and there is, at least there was a few years ago when i read tiktok's terms and conditions and blocked that shit in my firewall), as a murican citizen, would you want usa based companies to handle your data, or the chinese communist party? same goes for europeans or any other nation. personally i'd rather give my burner card data to amazon/google instead of aliexpress/wechat and i also stopped buying chinese smart devices a few years ago. there are just way too many question marks about them and i don't want to waste my time with investigating the very device before buying, be it a phone or a vacuum cleaner lol: https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2024/10/robot-vacuum-cleaners-hacked-to-spy-on-insult-owners

bottom line is that it's a war. bans for huawei, zte and tiktok are part of it. whether the ban is fair or not doesn't matter. too bad murica (and europe) are already screwed in way too many fields. they shouldn't have let china manufacture everything, yet they are doing exactly this, from electronics to industrial materials like epoxy
Promote excellence to your own youth, promote trash to your adversaries youth. This is a unique moment in history where a country as China is able to alter algorithms and literally reach millions of Western kids trough their own software.

Also if you turns things around, apps/websites like YouTube, Facebook, Instagram and X aren’t legal in China, it kinda becomes a self fulfilling prophecy at that point, you’re definitely not talking about equal terms anymore.

It think it was in this thread that I pointed to the possibility of states abusing social media when you had all the demonstrations at universities, I just don’t see why they won’t do that if they have the possibility, especially with TikTok where the demography simply is younger compared to Facebook or X, or at least here. Received heat for it when I opted it if I remember correctly. Maybe even the recent Romanian elections have a place in this discussion with all the Russian accounts
 

icemaη

Rab's Husband - The Regista
Moderator
Aug 27, 2008
36,357
the point of the article what @U Picciriddu posted is a bit more nuanced though. it's not about making the content addictive. scrolling, interacting IS addictive on its own. the big difference is that in china they show your kids some scientific stuff, creative, educational, and of course patriotic content. everywhere else (not only in the us) it's the junk time wasting stuff

as for "every app collects everything" argument, even if there's no difference between the apps (and there is, at least there was a few years ago when i read tiktok's terms and conditions and blocked that shit in my firewall), as a murican citizen, would you want usa based companies to handle your data, or the chinese communist party? same goes for europeans or any other nation. personally i'd rather give my burner card data to amazon/google instead of aliexpress/wechat and i also stopped buying chinese smart devices a few years ago. there are just way too many question marks about them and i don't want to waste my time with investigating the very device before buying, be it a phone or a vacuum cleaner lol: https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2024/10/robot-vacuum-cleaners-hacked-to-spy-on-insult-owners

bottom line is that it's a war. bans for huawei, zte and tiktok are part of it. whether the ban is fair or not doesn't matter. too bad murica (and europe) are already screwed in way too many fields. they shouldn't have let china manufacture everything, yet they are doing exactly this, from electronics to industrial materials like epoxy
I perfectly understand the nuance it's trying to make. I see it as more to do with China wanting to control what their citizens see vs them trying to influence American minds by withholding scientific content. The latter is an outcome of how very little oversight the big tech companies have in the US. China is quick to bring in laws to counter addictive behaviour with kids. Western countries can do the same, like Australia is doing for example. Instead we have Meta deciding that they want to do away with factchecking, Roblox deciding that they'll add parental controls and put the onus on them instead of being more aggressive with content moderation etc. I have a problem with tech companies (and others) scream "won't you think of the children" when they don't either and are only driven by value to the shareholder.
In a way it's funny that in the past few weeks we were seeing memes Americans were posting of how the UK were handling hate speech on social media and screaming free speech, while this week they straight up banned a whole platform.
Btw, I guess we should be glad that Juventus is not very popular these days as the best place to get more information about me is on Tuz and the Chinese and the Russians are not hanging about here trying to farm data. Well, except for Alex-444, he's one of the good ones.
 

s4tch

Senior Member
Mar 23, 2015
33,663
I perfectly understand the nuance it's trying to make. I see it as more to do with China wanting to control what their citizens see vs them trying to influence American minds by withholding scientific content. The latter is an outcome of how very little oversight the big tech companies have in the US. China is quick to bring in laws to counter addictive behaviour with kids. Western countries can do the same, like Australia is doing for example. Instead we have Meta deciding that they want to do away with factchecking, Roblox deciding that they'll add parental controls and put the onus on them instead of being more aggressive with content moderation etc. I have a problem with tech companies (and others) scream "won't you think of the children" when they don't either and are only driven by value to the shareholder.
In a way it's funny that in the past few weeks we were seeing memes Americans were posting of how the UK were handling hate speech on social media and screaming free speech, while this week they straight up banned a whole platform.
Btw, I guess we should be glad that Juventus is not very popular these days as the best place to get more information about me is on Tuz and the Chinese and the Russians are not hanging about here trying to farm data. Well, except for Alex-444, he's one of the good ones.
is hungary a western country? we banned the use of self-owned smart devices in schools. you can use the schools' computers on class if required, but you have to deposit your phone (tablet, smartwatch) first thing in the morning and you can pick it up by the end of the day. not sure it's the right step. it's a bit like alcohol prohibition a good 100 years ago

chinese regulation of content is actually smarter than any ban or the apparent western approach. at the same time they are trying to flood western spaces with junk, so there goes their good intentions. it's simply self interest and i'm fine with that. banning tiktok comes from self interest too

i'm sure chinese and russians are everywhere in the public domain, even if you don't see them around
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 6, Guests: 121)