He should be at least an improvement over Asa, Licht and maybe MdS. Good enough for his price.
No! Absolutely not!
Prime Licht shits all over him. He's probably better than current Licht.
- - - Updated - - -
There are those of us who always choose to give the benefit of the doubt to every single transfer, regardless of how trash or garbage it is; those posters are also usually supportive of Jabronis and Bidones, particularly Italian ones, believing that every transfer will become a Pirlo or Barzagli, ignoring the Malakas, Accidental Footballers, and Elias in between.
There are also those who choose to remain pessimistic, observe past trends, and deploy a little bit of perspective. Dumpian is no spring chicken, and his best year(s) and a half were spent at a mediocre mid table team like Torino. Even at his best, he was nothing special. 5 years for a Jabroni (can't wait to see how much we're paying him) is a bad deal.
It's also important to note that Serie A experience and being Italian don't count for shit if you're a bang average player. If you're a star, you'll shine anywhere, regardless of whether you speak Swahili or Bahasa, and irrespective of Serie A experience.