out now?


  • Total voters
    166
  • Poll closed .

Salvo

J
Moderator
Dec 17, 2007
62,842
Criticising tevez for one game he was literally the heart and soul of the team I can't remember any other player having so much impact
I'm not criticising anyone
My point is that our attack is arguable better and significantly deeper than it was
And saying we shouldn't sell strikers to fund midfield buys
 

dolph

Senior Member
Mar 30, 2006
2,599
But aren't results what matter for us to evaluate a manager?

What if a manager has one game plan, but that game plan gets him very good results. Surely he should get credit for the results he got, despite any apparent weaknesses that he may have?

Klopp plays in one way, but that way has been enough for him to beat some very good managers, and get results that have made him legendary for B.Dortmund and soon for Pool as well.

Would he be a better manager if he was able to be more tactically flexible, and read games better? Of course, but has he been achieving results above and beyond what is expected of him? IMO that is unarguable.

- - - Updated - - -



The guy reached a CL final last season FFS, not 5 years ago, last season.

I really don't understand how managers are evaluated over here, its like you are only as good as last weeks result. I cannot fathom how anyone can say Allegri hasn't done a fantastic job at Juve. Sure he is expected to win Serie A every season, but look at his results in the CL, he's had better results than teams that have much better squads and bigger budgets like Barcelona and Bayern. Allow him to buy superstars, and guarantee that he doesn't have to sell important stars every season, and then blame him for not winning the CL. Until then, its extremely unfair for anyone to say he has done anything short of a fantastic job.
True about Klopp. Next week he will have reached two CHL finals with fucking Dortmund and Pool and for some posters here he is apparently the worst coach in the universe.

About Allegri, there is things he does very well and there are things he cant do. He is a top level coach but he has some flaws as well. That really has not changes in the four years he has been here. Result wise he has done a good job here, but I think there are other managers out there who could do just as well, and at the same time play some positive attractive football. I know it is a big no no around here, but most of us watch 55-60 games with Juve a year, and for the last three seasons, with the exception of the second half of the 2015/2016 and second half of the 2016/2017 seasons we play some horrible football, and it could be nice to tune into a Juve game and feel excited about what you are going to see.
 

Hust

Senior Member
Hustini
May 29, 2005
93,703
Tevez did sweet fuck all in the final, Morata was clutch

I'd choose Sandro over evra (when in form)
Higuain over Morata in general but that year he was amazing

Our midfield from the final was head and shoulders over our current
Our bench is much better now

My point is there is no point weakening our attack to strengthen the defence/ midfield
I see you are supporting this point in a couple places. Question for you, knowing we don't have a mega budget to work with, how do you strengthen our midfield then without selling? I'm assuming our only options are buying in Italy (Pellegrini, Torreira, Cristante, or Bentancur type deals) and hope for the best.

- - - Updated - - -

But aren't results what matter for us to evaluate a manager?

What if a manager has one game plan, but that game plan gets him very good results. Surely he should get credit for the results he got, despite any apparent weaknesses that he may have?

Klopp plays in one way, but that way has been enough for him to beat some very good managers, and get results that have made him legendary for B.Dortmund and soon for Pool as well.

Would he be a better manager if he was able to be more tactically flexible, and read games better? Of course, but has he been achieving results above and beyond what is expected of him? IMO that is unarguable.

- - - Updated - - -



The guy reached a CL final last season FFS, not 5 years ago, last season.

I really don't understand how managers are evaluated over here, its like you are only as good as last weeks result. I cannot fathom how anyone can say Allegri hasn't done a fantastic job at Juve. Sure he is expected to win Serie A every season, but look at his results in the CL, he's had better results than teams that have much better squads and bigger budgets like Barcelona and Bayern. Allow him to buy superstars, and guarantee that he doesn't have to sell important stars every season, and then blame him for not winning the CL. Until then, its extremely unfair for anyone to say he has done anything short of a fantastic job.
:tup:
 

JCK

Biased
JCK
May 11, 2004
125,388
Our team in 2014-15 had Tevez, Pirlo, Morata, Vidal, Bonucci...

If you compare that team to what we have now the decline is obvious. You're right. Our roster is just weaker now.
Thank you very much! And the past two summers were two steps backwards. Last season Allegri managed to find balance and a winning formula but after last summer it was simply impossible, the squad has been annihilated.

- - - Updated - - -

Arguable

Our squad overall is better we just have no midfield grunt
Our bench is far deeper now, we have more attacking talent
Fullbacks are iffy I'll give you that
How can our squad be better if the midfield grunt (our strongest asset) is absent.
We have a better bench maybe in terms of names but in terms of balance it is not.
And the fullbacks are iffy.

That there is a lot of areas in the team which makes the squad overall worse.
 

Salvo

J
Moderator
Dec 17, 2007
62,842
Thank you very much! And the past two summers were two steps backwards. Last season Allegri managed to find balance and a winning formula but after last summer it was simply impossible, the squad has been annihilated.

- - - Updated - - -



How can our squad be better if the midfield grunt (our strongest asset) is absent.
We have a better bench maybe in terms of names but in terms of balance it is not.
And the fullbacks are iffy.

That there is a lot of areas in the team which makes the squad overall worse.
By squad I meant depth and overall quality players in the side

Balance is a different story, Padoin was on our bench in the final against Barca

Mario played out of his mind and Cuadrado played really well also last year which masked the lack of physical presence in our midfield
Khedira was a lot better as well

Once again I'm just saying if you throw one or two dynamic technical players in our midfield we'd have a better squad overall than either of the finals
Which is why I don't agree with selling important pieces (Dybala, Higuain) to fund midfield moves
 

Salvo

J
Moderator
Dec 17, 2007
62,842
I also think Allegri has known for a while that this side has a massive weakness in the midfield and he has really struggled to find a solution
Wouldn't surprise me if he starts demanding if he is to stay
 

Quetzalcoatl

It ain't hard to tell
Aug 22, 2007
66,774
If Max was a defensive coach, we would have advanced vs. Madrid.

I still to this day don't know how someone watches us play with 2 strikers walking around up front and call us defensive. Right off the bat with 2 strikers, you are not defensive. When both strikers do nothing in defense, you are definitely not defensive.
You wouldnt say Capello's 4-4-2 with Del Piero and Trezeguet was a defensive team?
 

Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
38,987
About Allegri, there is things he does very well and there are things he cant do. He is a top level coach but he has some flaws as well. That really has not changes in the four years he has been here. Result wise he has done a good job here, but I think there are other managers out there who could do just as well, and at the same time play some positive attractive football. I know it is a big no no around here, but most of us watch 55-60 games with Juve a year, and for the last three seasons, with the exception of the second half of the 2015/2016 and second half of the 2016/2017 seasons we play some horrible football, and it could be nice to tune into a Juve game and feel excited about what you are going to see.
I think he had to step down when his heart told him to, and that was after Cardiff.
The board was wrong into making up his mind to stay. Definitely something broke that summer. He was not meant to continue if he was not fully into it.

- - - Updated - - -

You wouldnt say Capello's 4-4-2 with Del Piero and Trezeguet was a defensive team?
Yeh, i dont understand what mike said in that post tbh. You can very well play a very defensive game with 2 strikers (capellos 442 in juve for example). In fact, you can play very defensive regardless of formations, it all depends on the tactics and players you use. Obviously there are some formations that are more defensive and other more offensive, but the final line is traced by the Coach and what he orders to players and which players he uses.
 

zizinho

Senior Member
Apr 14, 2013
51,816
You cant reach CL finals with a limited squad on a tight budget while playing offensive attractive football. You have to play defensively.






Oh wait.. Klopp did it twice.. with 2 different clubs.. and weaker squads... on tight budgets.
Piszczek Subotic Hummels Schmelzer
Gundogan Kehl/Bender
Kuba Gotze Reus
Lewa

all at their primes/peak. this a limited squad to you?

- - - Updated - - -

I think he had to step down when his heart told him to, and that was after Cardiff.
The board was wrong into making up his mind to stay. Definitely something broke that summer. He was not meant to continue if he was not fully into it.

- - - Updated - - -



Yeh, i dont understand what mike said in that post tbh. You can very well play a very defensive game with 2 strikers (capellos 442 in juve for example). In fact, you can play very defensive regardless of formations, it all depends on the tactics and players you use. Obviously there are some formations that are more defensive and other more offensive, but the final line is traced by the Coach and what he orders to players and which players he uses.
You wouldnt say Capello's 4-4-2 with Del Piero and Trezeguet was a defensive team?
he means, if Allegri was a defensive coach, he would have defended with 9 players instead of 8, like we do when HD is together on the pitch.
 

Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
38,987
I see.

Still, for me is pretty clear he is a defense oriented coach. Allegri himself have said previously that he values the "1-0" result. It tells you what his aim is and the discipline he follows. He is italian (and no im not being racist) and italians come from a very particular football enviroment and are prepared in a very particular football school of coaching.

And this doesnt mean it is bad, as it has been shown numerous times 1 0 results are favorable in certain situations, especially when you know how to defend. But this team is not compatible with allegris tactics anymore, the reasons being multiple, but the result is that we are simply playing not up to it. In short words.

We have an array of offensive wingers that are going nowhere next season (more could even come)...so we must use them in a wingbased formation. But it seems wingbased offensive formations are not his cup of tea. On top of that our weak midfield and weak defense unbalance the whole team. Yeah, we can bring new players to fix this, but our systematic problem will continue there because we simply cant play offensively, we rarely can impose our game and attack. And this cant be fixed easily as far as i can tell.
 

MikeM

Footballing Hipster celebrating 4th place with Tuz
Sep 21, 2008
12,850
You wouldnt say Capello's 4-4-2 with Del Piero and Trezeguet was a defensive team?
Anyone playing 2 strikers will not be as defensive as a team playing only 1 striker. Unless you are Simeone's Atletico and really it's a 4-6-0.

But yes, Capello was a shocking coach who played defensively with great players. But he could have played even more defensively if he dropped one of ADP/Trez.
 

Hist

Founder of Hism
Jan 18, 2009
11,620
Piszczek Subotic Hummels Schmelzer
Gundogan Kehl/Bender
Kuba Gotze Reus
Lewa

all at their primes/peak. this a limited squad to you?

- - - Updated - - -





he means, if Allegri was a defensive coach, he would have defended with 9 players instead of 8, like we do when HD is together on the pitch.
First, he built that team using peanuts, and second yes.. this is a very limited team that should be nowhere near winning the Bundesliga against Bayern or reaching the CL final. Hummels and Lewa are obviously worldclass. Maybe Reus too if he isnt always injured. The rest are good but nothing special players and practically zero bench/depth.

You dont consider this group winning the league and reaching a final as punching above their weight? Do you consider this group as on par or equal to the Juve's that reached the finals? What about this liverpool squad?

If you consider reaching a final with Juve is impressive because we have limited squad and monies, then doing the same with BVB and Pool is twice as impressive. Our squads have been heads and shoulders above theirs.

- - - Updated - - -

And in both those seasons Klopp finished 20+ points off first place in his league and won no trophies sooooooo.......

Also Dortmund 2012/13 is just as strong if not stronger than the current juventus
No they are not.They may have had 3 or at the most 4 players that would start in our current squad but practically no bench. And in those positions we have high quality players not mediocre ones so it is barely a drop in quality (between Reus and DC for example).

Everyone likes to ignore the quality of Allegri's football and focus instead on results and take that alone to be a mark of genius.

Klopp combines both in Europe, getting young inexperienced small squads to bulldoze most teams in the CL and beating some bigger clubs along the way. and I'd imagine he would establish local dominance had he been Juve or Bayern's coach. Yet Klopp is seen as an idiot.

Would Allegri have taken BVB and Pool farther in Europe? Would those teams have done it in this bulldozing style? The answer is maybe for the first, hell no for the second and yet one is a lauded as a genius and the other an idiot.

Point is, most people here are waaaaaay too harsh on Klopp and if they apply the same standard they use for Allegri they'd see Klopp in a very different light. undervaluing Klopp is almost a psychological defense mechanism that we use to feel good about Allegri's life-draining approach.

- - - Updated - - -

Valencia is another example.

Wysłane z mojego FRD-L09 przy użyciu Tapatalka
how so what did they do.
 

Nedved96

Senior Member
Sep 1, 2017
7,198
And in both those seasons Klopp finished 20+ points off first place in his league and won no trophies sooooooo.......
Juventus have by far the best and deepest squad in Italy, Allegri is bound to win trophies regardless of how we play.

Klopp had the second best squad in Germany, and (about) the 5th best squad in England. Of course he isn't going to win as many trophies. His job is much harder.

Point is, most people here are waaaaaay too harsh on Klopp and if they apply the same standard they use for Allegri they'd see Klopp in a very different light. undervaluing Klopp is almost a psychological defense mechanism that we use to feel good about Allegri's life-draining approach.
Nailed it.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 7, Guests: 291)