Once they leave you (Juve) no longer has any say in their development. Juve can't call up Empoli and ask them why they aren't playing a youngster and expect Empoli to say SO SORRY we will play him now. Doesn't work like that. Often times it better to be immersed daily around talented players to learn from and fight for your minutes. Either our scouts absolutely SUCK at scouting potential or our board is mental for abusing ones with it.
If I was a promising youngster at Juve...I'd rather stay there on the B team with the ability to watch every single day players like ronaldo, buffon, etc train b/c I will learn more from them than I will the best player at say, Genoa or Palermo. Hands down I stay at Juve and fight for my place. I will play my hand and try to get the experience there rather than at some mediocre club with an Italian coach that prefers 30+ year old dinosaurs over young potential. No.Thank.You.
- - - Updated - - -
Looking at Rovella, he would walk into our current midfield...yet, here we are, using him as bait.
- - - Updated - - -
Well we are absolutely fucked if we think we are going to ever buy our way to an MVP type midfield.
if we can't run a business where we groom at least one talented midfielder then we should stop pretending with our B-team and youth camps. The best long term solution right now is put added emphasis on growing our youth setups. We have our hands on two decent CMs we have no business letting them go. Locatelli should be bought, but not at their expense.
- - - Updated - - -
Although you’re right in saying that once you leave Juventus on loan, the odds of coming back are pretty slim. We’re a particular case in that regard, sadly enough.
But what you’re saying in terms of training or playing is wrong. We’ve learned that lessons already years ago with Marrone. Players develop by many reasons but in particular the most important are: playing, playing on a suited level, and good coaching. Besides that there are the mental aspects and talent obviously, bus let’s take that for granted for the sake of the discussion.
If we take a recent example with Fagioli and Rovella; the first more talented and training with the big ones, the other less talented but played 20 Serie A games. Who would’ve developed more this year? This whole situation made Fagioli not playing for Italy U21 at the Euro’s aswel and the U23 games which he played were below level, as he probably missed match fitness. So to answer my own question, Rovella developed more. Fagioli basically missed a important year.
Just training will never be enough, young guys have to play in order to gain more experience and improve their skills. There’s indeed a risk of loaning players as those clubs aren’t obligated to use them every week, so a good solution has to be found (hence the U23 team). Besides that there’s something fundamentally wrong at Juventus in this regard and they should change that conservative mentality.
It will be interesting to see what this club will do, because we basically have 3 midfielders who followed a different way within this club and a decision should be made this summer:
- Fagioli: played mostly for U19, and has numerous games for U23, but has spent a year training with the senior squad, didn’t play much this season
- Ranocchia: full season U19, followed by a full season U23, played as much as possible in Serie C
- Rovella: bought for a high amount and loaned out, gained some Serie A experience