Mafia Game Zombie Discussion Thread. (4 Viewers)

[Osman]

Geez, ok.

I dont mean you, you arent the one who started the habit of closing threads in deadline, it has been so for every game. And I get it in part, to controll the traffic, and this forum, there is lots of traffic. But for this game, thats not necessarily bad, the more said, the better. Just a suggestion, that its not completely necessary to close it.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Dostoevsky]

Fine, I won't interfere any longer with it. I just saw it closed when it's a picture time so I did it.

 

[JBF]

What if he had changed his vote to Sadomin in the last minute?

I already posted that long ago when I made my goodbye post here

Read my response to Osman in the main thread.



It means I would know what role C/G that everybody has!

You're response is worthless with all due respect.

So?

 

[The Curr]

You're response is worthless with all due respect.

So?

It's pretty simple really.


I really didn't think Sadomin was a G. People only voted for him because of what I think was part of a joke (his really early vote for Kyle). Check the early part of the thread. He wasn't the only one to jump on Kyle straight away. it was just a joke. Sadomin wasn't around much during the day to change his vote or to see who he should really vote for (keep in mind that 3 people didn't vote at all).

Anyway, even if I had voted no lynch or stuck with my vote for Ahmed, it wouldn't have made a difference. You had more votes without me even getting involved.

You can see from the first day of the last game that's it's my style to change my vote at the last minute when my current vote won't count for anything.

 

[JBF]

Since it wouldn't make any difference, why the fuck did you change it with 3 minutes remaining for the deadline?


Except ofcourse because you knew I could change my vote thus making it a draw which could result in a G being lynched so early in the game.

 

[The Curr]

Since it wouldn't make any difference, why the fuck did you change it with 3 minutes remaining for the deadline?

Because...

I really didn't think Sadomin was a G. People only voted for him because of what I think was part of a joke (his really early vote for Kyle). Check the early part of the thread. He wasn't the only one to jump on Kyle straight away. it was just a joke. Sadomin wasn't around much during the day to change his vote or to see who he should really vote for

 

[JBF]

FFS, Sadomin wouldn't have been lynched even if you kept your vote



Cut the BS already.

 

[Alen]

Boys, have this discussion in the main thread so those players who aren't here can get a better picture when they decide to vote tomorrow.

 

[The Curr]

Boys, have this discussion in the main thread so those players who aren't here can get a better picture when they decide to vote tomorrow.

Done.

 

[SABSAB]

I dont mean you, you arent the one who started the habit of closing threads in deadline, it has been so for every game. And I get it in part, to controll the traffic, and this forum, there is lots of traffic. But for this game, thats not necessarily bad, the more said, the better. Just a suggestion, that its not completely necessary to close it.

Yeah but Osman the point is that stuff like JBFs post here(http://www.juventuz.com/forum/showpost.php?p=2418169&postcount=211) won't happen It preserves people from mistakes. Like how could he know that he was protected? Imagine he was the detective for example and he walks into the thread great guys I'm the detective you killed me well done. AND THEN LATER finds out he didn't died.

 

[Osman]

Boys, have this discussion in the main thread so those players who aren't here can get a better picture when they decide to vote tomorrow.

Copy/move their posts to the main thread Should have their interaction in full view for all in the other thread hehe, interesting outcome it shall be tommorrow

 

[Osman]

Yeah but Osman the point is that stuff like JBFs post here(http://www.juventuz.com/forum/showpost.php?p=2418169&postcount=211) won't happen It preserves people from mistakes. Like how could he know that he was protected? Imagine he was the detective for example and he walks into the thread great guys I'm the detective you killed me well done. AND THEN LATER finds out he didn't died.

Well then that should be allowed to happen

The lawyer is there, everyone should know of the possibility, if they blabb too much despite that, its their fault.

But from the impression I got, the thread is closed, not for the above unlikely scenario, but to give the narrator time and breathing space to do his narrating bussiness.

 

[SABSAB]

Well then that should be allowed to happen

The lawyer is there, everyone should know of the possibility, if they blabb too much despite that, its their fault.

But from the impression I got, the thread is closed, not for the above unlikely scenario, but to give the narrator time and breathing space to do his narrating bussiness.

You don't know how awesome it is to get some space to breath if you're the Narrator

 

[Osman]

Thats true, but unless they are nagging post the results now narrator, the narrator still have breathing space if the thread is open, and the players just speculate and post as usual (in this forum, that might mean 2-3 pages in few minutes, hehe).

 

[JCK]

Why is everyone against you, Osman?

 

[Osman]

Well some missunderstand ze purpose of this game Atleast here, in XT where I played this game I would get it because of my track record there

I mean, paranoia is good for this game, I incourage it But it should be game for game you base it on (clean slate after every game), not just the poster in general and get stuck on perceptions of them, heh. For example if I was a G, I wouldnt automatically whack Alen or Fred just because, but who I think might be likely special role etc.

Plus the "better" players can useful to your cause as a G still (even if obvious organizing threat), means they might get peeps who do everything they suggest, meaning most of it all is based on their judgement alone, and that may also mean their mistakes will be more damaging (seen games where usually really manipulative and good players get stuck on someone too quickly too often, lynch civilian after civilian due to people lsitening to them, get too trigger happy hehe).

 

[JBF]

Yeah but Osman the point is that stuff like JBFs post here(http://www.juventuz.com/forum/showpost.php?p=2418169&postcount=211) won't happen It preserves people from mistakes. Like how could he know that he was protected? Imagine he was the detective for example and he walks into the thread great guys I'm the detective you killed me well done. AND THEN LATER finds out he didn't died.

I would have never go with that attitude had I had a special role that's for sure.


But as Osman argued, players should be allowed to fuck up

 

[Osman]

Hey Alen, how come the detective investigated 2 days in a row? (before tonight), sounds like it from what I read, just corious, oughta be 1, based on only having 1 day played of voting, whacking and lynching, and in that case same with investigating too (otherwise gets extra investigation as a bonus).

P.S Nicely done JBF&Blondu but you were way too out there in how you hunted Jasper, did everything short of saying you are the detective ("Sheik is 100% civilian, I have way to prove it"), should played it low key.

 

[SABSAB]

Why should JBF except being lynched on day one. He posted that he's a C without knowing that he was saved.

 

[king Ale]

How do you know he didn't know he was saved? We all knew it, but he acted like he didn't know he was saved. It was me who came here to tell him that he is still alive.

Take a look at here:
http://www.juventuz.com/forum/showpost.php?p=2418169&postcount=211

It's JBF's post. And it was already clear that he was SAVED by the lawyer.

This is mine, two minutes later:
http://www.juventuz.com/forum/showpost.php?p=2418181&postcount=213

He KNEW well that he was alive.