Let's compare Juve vs Milan (4 Viewers)

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
115,930
#42
++ [ originally posted by Juve89 ] ++


No! I have always admired gatusso, for the world class player he is...
And emerson IMO is on a lower stadium than gatusso....
Forza Gatusso!
You have to factor in Gattuso plays with Pirlo, Seedorf, and Kaka, three world class midfielders. If you put Gattuso next to Emerson in our midfield he would not be as effective and you could probably see a difference in the way he plays. Without playmakers around him he will struggle offensively IMO, while Emerson can pretty much do it all.
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
115,930
#44
++ [ originally posted by Menace ] ++
Seedorf worldclass? :D
Perhaps not this season, however in the past yes. I mean he can basically do it all in midfield and has won three European Cups with three different teams. This season though he has not been as good fortunately.
 

Menace

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2005
3,988
#45
++ [ originally posted by Andy ] ++


Perhaps not this season, however in the past yes. I mean he can basically do it all in midfield and has won three European Cups with three different teams. This season though he has not been as good fortunately.
Yes he can do it all in midfield on his day, He's like Recoba 7 or 8 great matchs a season and a dozen rubbish ones Seedorf always has been this way
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
115,930
#46
++ [ originally posted by Menace ] ++


Yes he can do it all in midfield on his day, He's like Recoba 7 or 8 great matchs a season and a dozen rubbish ones Seedorf always has been this way
I don't agree. In the Champions League run up in 2003 he was very good in every match, and last season he had a lot of good performances. Don't just factor in the Seedorf this season; he can do a lot better than that.
 

Juve89

The Farmer
May 27, 2004
3,420
#47
++ [ originally posted by Andy ] ++


You have to factor in Gattuso plays with Pirlo, Seedorf, and Kaka, three world class midfielders. If you put Gattuso next to Emerson in our midfield he would not be as effective and you could probably see a difference in the way he plays. Without playmakers around him he will struggle offensively IMO, while Emerson can pretty much do it all.
Ok, you have some good points BUT football is a team sport it isn't individually.
Yes Gatusso plays with Pirlo, Seedorf and Kaka but he would be just as good without them, and I have never said that I admire him by his skills offensively, he is my favourite player in Milan because of his way to play never to give up, and he has excellent defensive skills.
 

Menace

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2005
3,988
#48
++ [ originally posted by Andy ] ++


I don't agree. In the Champions League run up in 2003 he was very good in every match, and last season he had a lot of good performances. Don't just factor in the Seedorf this season; he can do a lot better than that.
He plays well in the big matchs, last season was the best season seedorf has played in milan, but he is far too inconsistent in serie a to be world class
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
115,930
#49
++ [ originally posted by Juve89 ] ++
Yes Gatusso plays with Pirlo, Seedorf and Kaka but he would be just as good without them
No he wouldn't. Without Pirlo he would not have anybody to give the ball to in a short distance. Without Kaka coming back and picking up the ball Gattuso would have to do more by himself. He is not that good going forward and his passing is far from excellent. What Gattuso does well though is shut down the opposition's attack, something Emerson also can do very well, however the latter is much better going forward. Emerson is the more complete and better player.
 

Juve89

The Farmer
May 27, 2004
3,420
#50
++ [ originally posted by Andy ] ++


No he wouldn't. Without Pirlo he would not have anybody to give the ball to in a short distance. Without Kaka coming back and picking up the ball Gattuso would have to do more by himself. He is not that good going forward and his passing is far from excellent. What Gattuso does well though is shut down the opposition's attack, something Emerson also can do very well, however the latter is much better going forward. Emerson is the more complete and better player.
Ok i'm not in a mood to discuss anything now because of the math exam but you have you're opinion and I have mine, they are different but that is good.
It wouldn't been any fun if everyone liked what I liked or admired what I admire.:)
 

Hambon

Lion of the Desert
Apr 22, 2005
8,073
#51
thats exactly what i was thinking....we are the champions they can all burn in he.... as far as i am concerned ....let us celebrate and plan for a repeat next season ...forza juve
 

Menace

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2005
3,988
#52
Who cares now, Milan is shit and seedorf is a lazy piece of shit :D
We are miles better then milan, better squad on paper my arse :howler:
28!
 

ZhiXin

Senior Member
Oct 1, 2004
10,321
#53
++ [ originally posted by sallyinzaghi ] ++
I dont think Pirlo had a very good season. Or maybe that was just the recent games. I tend to mix it up.
Wad u said is right Sally, Pirlo seemed rather inconsistent this season. At times he can play wonderfully, but I have seen some Milan games in which he can be really inconsistent and he is rightfully subbed off. Cambiasso did better than him
 

Daddi

Cuadrado is juan hell of a derby king!
Oct 27, 2004
7,900
#54
David Pizarro did better than both Pirlo and Seedorf, lets get him to boost up our midfield! ;)
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 4)