honestly, he just doesn't fit.
The only thing I kept thinking when Pereyra got injured was that I didn't want to see him come in. 4-3-1-2 is the formation for us, it is what brought us to the CL final. Cuadrado has no place in that formation.
I don't want to see important players like Morata and Dybala off position and a formation change just so he can play.
YES!!!
I totally agree on that. Have been trying to say it in million word posts, you summed up.
We are Cuadrado dependent when he plays. He is a very useful player, but the team gets unbalanced.
I agree, 4312 is the way to go. Allegri has to make things simpler. Play our best CF and best SS together and that's it. Use Pereyra, who succeeded at the AM position last year, as the AM. Marchisio-Khedira-Pogba should make a steady midfield. Use 2 fullbacks who can offer balance and provide width when needed, with Sandro and Sturaro (in the absence of Licht).
Now that Pereyra is out, Cuadrado has to start. But with a healthy Pereyra, he's a much better fit.
- - - Updated - - -
With this scheme, transition is much easier.
Our best team last year was with Pirlo out, Marchisio as a DM, Vidal-Pogba CMs, Pereyra AM.
Just try to repeat the closest to what it was. Allegri got lost in the middle of late transactions, little training time, a lot of injuries, options in the squad that don't really fit, like Zaza and Cuadrado.
Play a back 4 with two proper fullbacks who can defend and support the attack.
It would look like this, comparing to our best formation of last season:
14/15 - 15/16
Buffon - Buffon
Licht - Licht
Bonucci - Bonucci
Chiellini - Chiellini
Evra < Sandro (Sandro can provide offense, to me it's an improvement)
Marchisio - Marchisio
Pogba - Pogba
Vidal < Khedira (Compared to last season's Vidal, Khedira has been better)
Pereyra - Pereyra
Tevez > Dybala
Morata - Morata
This would ensue the easiest transition. Only 3 position changes, with improvement in 2 of them (LB, CM) compared to the players last season performance. Tevez would be replaced by Dybala, who obviously is not as good, but has loads of potential and is already showing results.
Just stick with the simple, Allegri. Play as close as a normal RB as you've got now (Caceres or Sturaro), use Pereyra as an AM, let Dybala and Morata be the starters.
Now with Pereyra out, I want to see Pogba tested in that position. If not, change the team for Cuadrado.