There are only two people who know the absolute truth, and they are both not talking until the end of the season.
All this arguing based largely on variables is only causing grief and anger to everyone on on this forum, especially since none of us here have even the faintest idea of how this all went down.
Now, allow me add some of my opinions, if I may, on this matter.
This is obviously a battle between the heart and the brain, and no matter what happens, neither the heart or brain is going to leave without scars.
Romantically speaking, it would be the ultimate if Alex were to stay another year and retire. Alex captures the heart. He is a romantic player, a player that you love, fall in love with, become emotionaly attached to, both for his on the field and off the field behaviour, performance, and grace.
That is absolutely without dispute, regardless of the level of admiration that you may have for him. The heart bypasses the brain when it comes to emotion, it doesn't allow for the brain to interject reasoning into the equation. And there is nothing wrong with that. Absolutely nothing. It is what makes us all fans of a player, a team, or a sport.
And the heart tells us that anything less than Alex retiring in a Juve jersey is as close to sacrilege as any of us could imagine.
However, the issue with only thinking through these things with your heart, and not allowing the brain to counterbalance these sway of emotions only prevents you from looking at some very real and pragmatic realizations.
Here is what my brain tells me, and some of the evidence for this reasoning can actually be found in other threads, if one puts the time in to connect the dots.
My brain is telling me that the overwhelming majority of people here on this thread, as well as articles that I have read, and many football pundits have stated on satellite radio that i listen to every morning, realize that in order for this club to take that essential step up to be one rung further up the ladder of European elite status, that the biggest change in the construct of this squad is to increase the quality of the attacker positions.
A position that Alex is currently grouped with.
In the current state, Alex is currently somewhere between a 4th and 5th choice striker. Now, one would say that based on talent alone, that is not where he should be,and I would tend to agree. However, this is the reality that has been brought upon us, by a coach who has helped engineer a fantastic 1 season turnaround.
We all see that he barely gets any playing time as it is with Vucinic, Quagliarella, and Matri currently ahead of him in the pecking order, and until recently Borriello was getting far more playing time than him. The situation would be multiplied tenfold next season if one or two new strikers are added next season. What playing time he has received this season would be reduced even more next season, to the point where it is possible that he could suffer the worst indiginty of all, and not even be on the bench for stretches at a time.
No one wants to see that. Not Juve, Not Alex, Not Us. To put "Alex Del Piero" and "useful" in the same sentence is an outrage, and an insult.
Pepe is useful.
Caceres is useful.
Alex is Legendary. Legendary players don't become useful. They play until they feel that they can no longer be who they were, and then leave.
And this is the conundrum. Juve have to move on from the Del Piero era. Not just physically, but psychologically. They need to be a team that can without him, and even moreso, realize that he won't be there to bail them out, such as he did against Lazio.
And Alex, I believe, knows this. He knows full well that changes are going to be made, that changes to the position on the pitch that he plays in are going to be made. He's many things, smart being among them.
And I feel that his heart and his brain are in perfect symmetry. He knows what he has accomplished, he knows that there isn't much more that he could possibly do as a primary component to the Juventus machine, and to be quite honest, he deserves to go to a place that will offer him new challenges, to play in a different part of the world, to play in a country that he obviously loves in the United States, and to be fairly compensated for this as well.
Keep in mind that he has been playing professional football in Italy for almost 20 years now. He's human. Being human means that in order to stimulate the mind and body, at the age of 37, new challenges are needed. New stimuli have to be set in front of you to maintain that level of love of your craft that you have had for 20 years now. We all want to see what is on the other side of the fence, regardless if the grass is indeed greener or not. We wouldn't be who we are if we weren't at least curious.
I can't fault him for being what we all are. Human. He has earned the right to think of himself first, for a change, if that is his wish. I can't fault the club for being who they are. A club, and more importantly, a business. Players sell merchandise, but winning, and winning big, are what keeps the paying public coming back. And eventually, the public finds a new hero. I've seen many, now in my 5th decade as a Juventus supporter. From Platini, to my beloved Roby, to my love Alex, to Zidane, to Nedved, to Gigi.
And that is the key. Juventus will always be Juventus. Controversy, tragedy, misfortunes have always befallen this club, and they have always bounced back with dignity. This Juventus will bounce back again post Del Piero. It will happen.
History has shown all of us that it has happened before.