Well, That's another point of veiw which I respect but dont agree.
A club is not just about financial and Technical aspects. There is something more. And I agree, If he is not good enough, doesn't matter to me if coach put him on the bench. The club is above all, but you should not forget that the club as the bigger picture, is made of these smaller things. Its these players that write their own history here which make a club like Juve that glorious.
Juventus, for quite some time, has actually been very stringent in terms of trying to maintain self-reliance, financially. It has to, as the owners can't simply bankroll losses at a whim, unlike others, particularly with regard to the impending FFP.
I perfectly understand your sentiment that a club (ideally) should be more than a business, in fact, sometimes more than a sporting organization even. To many it may reflect aspects of lifestyle, as well; things like values, comradery, whatever. It's a nice idea, of course, but where do you draw the line? Should Del Piero, in repayment for his long career, be on club salary forever? Does his contribution merit an irrefutable place on the field, forever? Further, should he sensibly be drawing the same wages as when he was in his prime? I mean, really, it isn't even an issue of disrespect to ask him to lower what he earns. It's just how it goes in the profession, naturally. For good reason, too.
2- While moving to another chapter you need to bring the identity of team to new player as well. Forget about the experience and spirit, What will be the impact of this style of management to young players? If a young player realize that, no matter how long or how good or how loyal he stay and play for this club, there will be no difference between him and others. And while they know one day they might just kicked out of club like Trez or asked to lower his wage like Del piero or buffon, do they still be as loyal as these legend? do they want to sacrifice themselves for this shirt or put the club interests above themselves? or they look at to this the same way, like a deal. when doesn't benefit them anymore, they will leave.
I see where you're coming from here, but again, it's an issue of when enough reaches enough. Del Piero is one of two proven winners left (alongside Buffon). He has it in his blood to win, and more importantly, to win with Juventus. The thing is, he's been alongside this core group of the "new" Juventus for quite sometime. Whatever magic he might have in those boots, words, tricks, whatever, must surely have been imparted by now. If it hasn't, then it never will be. Does keeping him, at the tail-end of his career, for yet another year, make much of a difference? I think not. I think letting him go would be in the best interests of the team. Think about it. "Del Piero retires." If nothing in the world could spur management (what, with the new stadium coming, too) to put in a
serious investment in hopes of netting us a true superstar, this would have to do it. They'd have no choice. On the other hand, Del Piero dragging out his career another year may soften their stance. They may think, again, "Okay, Del Piero stays and will play a substantial role." Where would that lead us? To another half-assed market policy upfront, I'm almost certain of it. The thing with him staying is his mere presence seems to dictate that he commands playing-time, especially with a weaker coach like Del Neri (Capello, meanwhile, was too strong a character to let a player walk all over him).
As for the rest, I think you're overstating it. Del Piero's had a long and distinguished career with the club. That's fact. Now? He barely resembles the player he used to be. That's also fact. The club can't coddle him until he reaches the need for an assisted-living facility. I can't imagine that younger players would see the club gently nudging him to call time on his career as some maltreatment. If anything, you could make that case with Trezeguet. Del Piero, though? Not really. I've never seen a player so well-treated at this stage of his career, actually. Perhaps Totti. Although, that new contract of his was the most foolish thing Roma's done in years (and that's a lot of foolhardy things they've done to compete with, too). Even Maldini, who played on way too long, took a big salary slashing.
3- When you say Millions, its sounds different. But its not like those 2.5 million we are cutting from Del piero wage is going to get us anywhere here. You are really short of income, you sell one of your players to cover that. Does this 2 ml really worth this? 2 million is not really that much money to show a legend like Del piero respect. Is it? And it's not lifetime, its one or two year max. It's not going to ruin these Five years plans of our board !
Millions is what it is. It's not small amounts we're talking about. Just because there's been plenty of waste through mistakes on part of the management in other areas doesn't somehow justify further waste on inflated and unnecessary contracts (again, simply to maintain some pretense of "respecting Del Piero").
4- We are wasting way to much money on fee and wage of useless player and throwing a lot of money out lately that now when you put this 2 million on the table as problem doesn't make sense. when you want fix that, you don't go start with your club legends. you don't offer Toni 3.5 ml and then ask Alex to reduce his to 2 ml. That in my idea, is lack of respect toward players who gave this club a lot.
Again, mistakes don't correct other mistakes.
As for Toni, word around the campfire is that his contract in its entirety will be worth 3.5m euro total (for this half of the season, and next season).
It's a bit vague.