and no perrota,who's been one of the most effective team players at the world cup?
i cant agree with you on this one.totti seems to be getting in a little bit of form,he's getting better as the tournament is progressing and he should be starting.del piero should be used as a 2nd half sub.he was more effective for us last season,and i think he'll be more effective this way for the NT too.
I have to agree that perrota has been good, but i dont think that Lippi is playing him where he is more comfort. I would use Camo this time bceause he is one of the few italian players who like to take on defenders. He had a good display against Ukraine, and when camo is on his day, is very difficult to defend against him.
About including Dp later, in part i agree with this but not completely, check the end of the post
I agree with you Hydde and I think it was a great post. axlrose85, will you really prefer Perrotta to Del Piero ?!
Hydde, and anyone else, I want your opinion on this :
a) if camo is injured - what lineup will you use ?
b) do you think there's any realistic chance that Del Piero will start in spite of what we want ? or what is best ?
a)If camo is injured i would return to Perrotta which is what we have been doing in most of the mathes.
b)To be sincere, i dont think Alex will start. If Lippi didnt gave him a chance against Ukraine´s defense, i dotn think he will do it against GER.
What is best for Italy.......... i think no one knows for sure....not even Lippi itself.
IMO if we take in consideration the player´s form, Toni in the start is a MUST. First of all, Germany have very tall defenders and the physical presence of Toni and his accurary are needed here. And like Riva said (i think was him), Toni's lack of goal is not totally his fault because he has been victim of great saves and bad luck, but his movement and positioning so far has been good.
I would use camo and alex because they did very well against them in the friendly.
About including DP in the second half. Well in part this is a good thing because DP is not in the best of his phsysical form i think. This let him come with energy to do his job. He looked tired against AUS but we need to take in consideration that he had to run a lot after Matrix´s dismissal, and he didnt do better becauise Italy´s midfield was simply non existant so is not solely his fault. Sadly, always when DP comes in, the Italian team is in that phase were everyone is thinking about defendin and this is when Dp doesnt do well. IN the australian game he was playing good infact but the dfenesively measures that were taken forcedfully, nullified him.
Lets take a loook at the last friendly played against GER. He(DP) played the whole game and did a very good overall performance (yes in that time he was in his best form with juventus but i dont think he have lost all of it right now)
We used this formation if im not wrong:
-------------Buff
Zaccardo-Canna-Nesta-Grosso
---------Pirlo--Rossi------
Camo--------------Dp
---------Gila --Toni--------
and this is the one i suggest now:
--------------Buff
Gross-Canna-Matrix-Zamb
--------Gattuso--Pirlo------
Camo-----Totti-------
-------------------DP--------
----------Toni----------
We now have Pirlo and Gattuso who are good deffensive players and zamrbotta to aid DP in that side of the field when needed. My only concern is that we are facing an INspired Germany which have conded 2 goals so far if im not wrong.