If this Top Kill does not work, then the only solution is building the relief wells which will take months to complete.
If this Top Kill does not work AND causes more damage to the well head (which looks like the case right now to the un-trained eye), then everyone is going to shovel even more shit towards BP's way.
Folks, you can't have it both ways. Everybody was urging them to try and stop the gusher NOW instead of waiting for the relief wells, which is fine. But if this causes the flow rate to worsen then you will just have to accept that as a casualty of the whole "have to do something regardless of consequence" mindset. Just like Keynesian economics, Monday-morning engineering quarterbacktry [sic] usually ends up causing more damage.
If this Top Kill does not work AND causes more damage to the well head (which looks like the case right now to the un-trained eye), then everyone is going to shovel even more shit towards BP's way.
Folks, you can't have it both ways. Everybody was urging them to try and stop the gusher NOW instead of waiting for the relief wells, which is fine. But if this causes the flow rate to worsen then you will just have to accept that as a casualty of the whole "have to do something regardless of consequence" mindset. Just like Keynesian economics, Monday-morning engineering quarterbacktry [sic] usually ends up causing more damage.
