He's had a mixed record, similar to every other top team in recent years.
People think Padoin was a bad signing, remember Bébé? Anderson? Barca on Ibra?
At the end of the day ya'll are just arguing for the sake of arguing.
I don't think he's good enough to get the right players at the right price OR have good backups if he fails. The sad fact is an italian will always overrate italians.
If we can get somebody better, don't renew, otherwise, keep the fucker.