May I ask why?
If you are solely comparing the two players on talent alone, ramirez is the more talented player.
This move, if it were to happen, is the ultimate Boom or Bust transfer.
If ramirez develops into the player that a lot of people think that he will, then this would be a master stroke of a transfer that hasn't been seen around these parts in quite a while. If it doesn't work, then it would be an abject failure.
However, these types of moves need to be made once in a while. Sometimes chances need to be taken, and I would rather take a chance on a 20 year old with exciting potential.