I've never seen Rugani as a bad defender. He might not be world-class, but he’s always been calm on the ball, reliable, and rarely error-prone. Maybe if he'd joined a team like Lazio or Fiorentina instead of spending years behind Juve’s backline, his career would’ve taken a different turn. In my opinion, aside from all the media hype, De Ligt didn’t really offer anything more than Rugani defensively. Still, Italian defenders often come into their own after 30, just look at Barzagli, who only really shined later on. I really hope he stays and finally gets the trust he deserves. Honestly, he’s way more dependable than guys like Kelly.