So you join the forum in 2007 & wait 3 yrs to waist your second post on Molinaro?
Moli is far from being a bad player, but for some reason he became the foci of much abuse: unwarrented much of the time.
No, he was bad. He had his moments of good in defense. But going forward, he was pretty much a circus clown in clown shoes who sent his crosses into the parking lot outside the stadium.
And after proving he could defend for a couple of matches, he would outright lose matches for us -- with the post-match comments in goal.com saying things like, "He should never play in a Juve jersey again." His defensive errors were so bad that I would catch myself saying, "Well, at least Boumsong would play well for a good 80 minutes."
I don't know how much more evidence you need for "bad". He'd be OK in Serie B, but not A.