Again! Your post negates yourself! It's just how this forum works, some things and arguments are done excessively, including gloatings.
I kind of confused as to what's the point you're trying to make here. But let me try it. People made assesments of how good Marchisio can be. Some of us at some point thought that he'll never be as good as this while another group people thought that he'll become a great player. That's how you got the "either you're with us or you're against us". These two groups are just making their opinion consistent through time, nothing unfair with that for me, contrary to what you're thinking. I can see that you're trying to tell me that you've fallen for neither groups and people should be like that too. This is where I think you got it wrong. Nothing unfair about choosing sides based on their opinions, people are also free to choose neither side.