[Champions League] Bayern München vs JUVENTUS (April 2, 2013) (190 Viewers)

[Vlad]

Still not offside, both his feet are well onside.

Mandzukic's head was in front of our defender. Every part of the body with which you can score counts.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[alexjuventino]

Still not offside, both his feet are well onside.

His body is offsides

 

[Nzoric]

I've seen it before on TV.
It's definitive offside position.

It's not. And even if he were in offside, Buffon didn't deflect the ball, he pushed it with intention to the side and made a mistake, which means he played him onside. It's all in the rules guys, read them.

 

[Joe]

It wasn't offside.

Good call by the linesmen.

We got, for the lack of a better word, obliterated.

Different game plan next week hopefully. Bring the fight to them, we can't try and absorb attacks. Not from a team like this. They'll kill us like they did today.

 

[Juve_fanatic]

Irony. Most of optimistic fans here sound like the ones at Celtic forum after they lost at home 3-0.

Except we didnt fucking loose 3-0 at home you piece of shit!!

- - - Updated - - -

Irony. Most of optimistic fans here sound like the ones at Celtic forum after they lost at home 3-0.

Except that we didnt loose 3-0 at home you peace of shit and we are not fucking Celtic and Juventus Stadium isnt Celtic fucking Park!

 

[Vlad]

It's not. And even if he were in offside, Buffon didn't deflect the ball, he pushed it with intention to the side and made a mistake, which means he played him onside. It's all in the rules guys, read them.

It is offside. It doesn't matter Buffon reflected the ball. Time of the shooting is important. In this situation it counts as passing the ball.

Tuttosport "Siamo al 63' quando un tiro dalla distanza di Gustavo impegna Buffon; sulla ribattuta si avventa Mandzukic (in fuorigioco) che serve al centro Mueller per il più facile dei tap-in vincenti."

 

[runner0xff]

Hm Somewhat reminiscent of a Del Neri post match comment but only with respect to the european competition.

disagree. The only thing i read in del neri comments was something like "We played very well. We are on the right track blablabla"

 

[john1987]

Still not offside, both his feet are well onside.

Nzoric offside expert level 4000.

Refer to above post.

 

[Nzoric]

His body is offsides

Look at Chiellini's foot behind him. Not an offside.

- - - Updated - - -

It is offside. It doesn't matter Buffon reflected the ball. Time of the shooting is important. In this situation it counts as passing the ball.
http://www.tuttosport.com/calcio/ch.../Troppo+Bayern+per+la+Juve:+bianconeri+ko+2-0

If Buffon in purpose pushes to ball to the side it means that it's a new situation and everyone is played onside. If it's a deflection it does't count as a new situation.

Buffon pushed it to the side on purpose, he was in control of that ball.

 

[Joe]

Except we didnt fucking loose 3-0 at home you piece of shit!!

- - - Updated - - -



Except that we didnt loose 3-0 at home you peace of shit and we are not fucking Celtic and Juventus Stadium isnt Celtic fucking Park!

 

[swag]

Offside or not doesn't matter. We're arguing the nickel and iron content in the spikes driven into Jesus Christ's hands for his crucifixion.

 

[Vlad]

Look at Chiellini's foot behind him. Not an offside.

- - - Updated - - -



If Buffon in purpose pushes to ball to the side it means that it's a new situation and everyone is played onside. If it's a deflection it does't count as a new situation.

Buffon pushed it to the side on purpose, he was in control of that ball.

No those are not the rules. Shooting is like passing the ball. Check it up. It was offside. Doesn't matter Buffon reflected the ball. What if someone tried to pass to a player in offside position and Buffon touched the ball?

 

[acmilan]

I was sure it was offiside in real time but after a replay or two, think it was too close to call and giving advantage to the attacking player, when not certain, is within the rules.

in the above pic, one can see how Mandzukic's head - the most forward part of his body with which he can score - is actually very much in line with the defender's trailing foot.

 

[Nzoric]

Offside or not doesn't matter. We're arguing the nickel and iron content in the spikes driven into Jesus Christ's hands for his crucifixion.

Spot on

Nice use of language there, *clap*

 

[Goodfella]

Look at Chiellini's foot behind him. Not an offside.

I believe it's offside if you're head is past the defender.

 

[Nzoric]

No those are not the rules. Shooting is like passing the ball. Check it up. It was offside. Doesn't matter Buffon reflected the ball. What if someone tried to pass to a player in offside position and Buffon touched the ball?

Shooting is like passing the ball, if you pass the ball to an opposing defender who gains control of it and then pushes it out to the striker who was in a offside position when you passed it, it's not an offside.

 

[Vlad]

I believe it's offside if you're head is past the defender.

That's right.

- - - Updated - - -

Shooting is like passing the ball, if you pass the ball to an opposing defender who gains control of it and then pushes it out to the striker who was in a offside position when you passed it, it's not an offside.

Buffon didn't have control of it. And in many situations that would be an offside also.

 

[swag]

Spot on

Nice use of language there, *clap*

If called offsides, Bayern would have continued to press hard and we could have conceded two more for a 3-0 finish. And who here is gonna doubt that could happen after what we all witnessed tonight?

So the point is really irrelevant.

 

[ALC]

I was sure it was offiside in real time but after a replay or two, think it was too close to call and giving advantage to the attacking player, when not certain, is within the rules.

in the above pic, one can see how Mandzukic's head - the most forward part of his body with which he can score - is actually very much in line with the defender's trailing foot.

the bolded part cannot be stressed enough.

 

[Nzoric]

If called offsides, Bayern would have continued to press hard and we could have conceded two more for a 3-0 finish. And who here is gonna doubt that could happen after what we all witnessed tonight?

So the point is really irrelevant.

2-0 is a gentle result considering the ass pillaging we suffered

Seriously, 5-0 wouldn't have been unfair.