Serie A: Juventus vs Parma [April 16 , 2008] (18 Viewers)

OP
JCK

JCK

Biased
JCK
Thread Starter #461
May 11, 2004
125,390
  • Thread Starter
    • Thread Starter #461
    Juve Revolution said:
    So basically , any 2 on 1 situations where a pass is given is offside then ? I can think of countless examples that completely defy that ; another thing , if it was offside , that one defender was the only pne covering for Trez and apart from him there was obviously no one covering Trezeguet . The linesman was in perfect position and I think he would have easilly spotted the offside had the rule stated that there had to be 2 players covering .



    Does anyone happen to have the link to the fifa rules .
    Click to expand...
    We have the football rules in a thread in MIsc Soccer.
     

    Buy on AliExpress.com

    tibike

    Senior Member
    #462
    Dec 11, 2007
    1,147
    #462
    Juve Revolution said:
    So basically , any 2 on 1 situations where a pass is given is offside then ? I can think of countless examples that completely defy that ; another thing , if it was offside , that one defender was the only pne covering for Trez and apart from him there was obviously no one covering Trezeguet . The linesman was in perfect position and I think he would have easilly spotted the offside had the rule stated that there had to be 2 players covering .
    Click to expand...
    The problem is that it's usually the goalkeeper and ONE defender. And because one defender was ahead of Trez, the linesman though everything is all right. But it wasn't because the defender was the last player and thus Trez was offside.

    And to the 2 on 1 situations: in those cases, there are 2 players ahead: the last defender and the last goalkeeper, because the goalkeeper counts as a player.
     
    rounder

    rounder

    Blindman
    #463
    Jun 13, 2007
    7,233
    #463
    Alen said:
    No man, in these situations the guy who made the pass was in front of the other guy. When you pass the ball backwards then it's not an offside even if there are 0 rival players in front of you.
    Click to expand...
    JCK said:
    Which makes the linesman incompetent because he doesn't know the rules. As Alen said, in a 2 on 1 situation if the ball is played on or behind the ball line then it is not offside, think Bonera passing to Inzaghi, think Kaka passing to Inzaghi.
    Click to expand...
    Yeah , I know that if the ball is passed back then it's obviously not offside . I never knew two players had to be covering for a through pass though , it's just that I've never really heard of it .
     
    Alen

    Alen

    Ѕenior Аdmin
    #464
    Apr 2, 2007
    53,998
    #464
    Juve Revolution said:
    So basically , any 2 on 1 situations where a pass is given is offside then ? I can think of countless examples that completely defy that ; another thing , if it was offside , that one defender was the only pne covering for Trez and apart from him there was obviously no one covering Trezeguet . The linesman was in perfect position and I think he would have easilly spotted the offside had the rule stated that there had to be 2 players covering .



    Does anyone happen to have the link to the fifa rules .
    Click to expand...
    http://www.juventuz.com/forum/showpost.php?p=1614226&postcount=16077
     
    rounder

    rounder

    Blindman
    #465
    Jun 13, 2007
    7,233
    #465
    tibike said:
    The problem is that it's usually the goalkeeper and ONE defender. And because one defender was ahead of Trez, the linesman though everything is all right. But it wasn't because the defender was the last player and thus Trez was offside.

    And to the 2 on 1 situations: in those cases, there are 2 players ahead: the last defender and the last goalkeeper, because the goalkeeper counts as a player.
    Click to expand...
    Thank you , that was the answer I was looking for , I didn't count the goalkeeper as a player , now it makes sense . :pint:
     
    cyril

    cyril

    Let's roll
    #467
    Jul 6, 2006
    2,689
    #467
    Solid game by juventus, didnt waste any more points on weak teams, which is always good, cl is getting closer and closer :p

    Ive got to ask about tiagos performance? what did you guys see :p any improvements?

    I know most you have lost faith in him, from my personal and humble opinion Ive noticed a steady improvement and I do believe he'll show his worth. Aslong as he starts, especially alongside sissoko
     
    rounder

    rounder

    Blindman
    #468
    Jun 13, 2007
    7,233
    #468
    cyril said:
    Solid game by juventus, didnt waste any more points on weak teams, which is always good, cl is getting closer and closer :p

    Ive got to ask about tiagos performance? what did you guys see :p any improvements?

    I know most you have lost faith in him, from my personal and humble opinion Ive noticed a steady improvement and I do believe he'll show his worth. Aslong as he starts, especially alongside sissoko
    Click to expand...
    He has been given his chances , I hoped he would have take them better . I think he proved he is a good player , but only just that .
     
    cyril

    cyril

    Let's roll
    #471
    Jul 6, 2006
    2,689
    #471
    He is a good player indeed, I just feel that alongside sissoko he can work wonders, he really reminds of pirlo hes got that touch in him.

    I see youre from lebanon where do you live there?
     
    rounder

    rounder

    Blindman
    #473
    Jun 13, 2007
    7,233
    #473
    cyril said:
    He is a good player indeed, I just feel that alongside sissoko he can work wonders, he really reminds of pirlo hes got that touch in him.

    I see youre from lebanon where do you live there?
    Click to expand...
    I don't think we can start comparing him to Pirlo just yet but he defintely has that special touch .


    El Koura , up in the north . I'm guessing you're from Beirut .
     
    v1rtu4l

    v1rtu4l

    Senior Member
    #476
    Mar 4, 2008
    6,349
    #476
    Juve Revolution said:
    I don't think we can start comparing him to Pirlo just yet but he defintely has that special touch .
    Click to expand...
    sry, pirlo is really way out of tiagos range .... but did u see cigarini ? i think it was him, that made a great long range pass to the right wing, just after entering the field... that is more pirlo'esque ;)
     
    You must log in or register to reply here.

    Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 18)