Serie A 2019/20 (27 Viewers)

Status
Not open for further replies.

CarloP

Senior Member
#2,042
Jan 24, 2010
618
#2,042
The play was initially ruled offside. VAR looked at that screen capture and said it was clear enough to award Inter the goal, which it clearly wasn't.
 
Vlad

Vlad

In Allegri We Trust
#2,045
May 23, 2011
22,748
#2,045
j0ker said:
Seriously?

His whole head is beyond the line and his shoulder, too.
Click to expand...
Is his head or shoulder closer to keeper or is it his knee? Looks like knee to me, which isnt offside then. But its a tough call either way. Are people screaming of conspiracy now?

- - - Updated - - -

Post Ironic said:
Wat? His entire head and half his chest are offside.
Click to expand...
I hate defending this :lol: but the angle is really bad
 
kao_ray

kao_ray

Senior Member
#2,046
Feb 28, 2014
6,567
#2,046
Post Ironic said:
Wat? His entire head and half his chest are offside.
Click to expand...
I think it's on side. The right foot of the Parma player is a bit ahead than the head and the right shoulder of Candreva. There are two main optical illusions at play here. The first one is that the Parma player is way closer to the camera and the second is that the lines are crossing the body of Candreva but if you look closely, his foot is at the same place as his right shoulder. A very close call but it's a regular goal for me.
 
Post Ironic

Post Ironic

Senior Member
#2,047
Feb 9, 2013
41,973
#2,047
Vlad said:
Is his head or shoulder closer to keeper or is it his knee? Looks like knee to me, which isnt offside then. But its a tough call either way. Are people screaming of conspiracy now?
Click to expand...
That is irrelevant in this case, because both his shoulder and head are beyond the last defender which means scoring parts of his body were in an offside position. It doesn’t matter if his knee was more offside than the rest of him. If this were the case a player 5 yards offside could just stick his knee out to be on
 
Vlad

Vlad

In Allegri We Trust
#2,048
May 23, 2011
22,748
#2,048
Post Ironic said:
That is irrelevant in this case, because both his shoulder and head are beyond the last defender which means scoring parts of his body were in an offside position. It doesn’t matter if his knee was more offside than the rest of him. If this were the case a player 5 yards offside could just stick his knee out to be on
Click to expand...
His shoulder and head arent ahead. Look closer and compare it to his knee. The angle is bad but he is in line with Parma player.
 
Post Ironic

Post Ironic

Senior Member
#2,049
Feb 9, 2013
41,973
#2,049
Vlad said:
His shoulder and head arent ahead. Look closer and compare it to his knee. The angle is bad but he is in line with Parma player.
Click to expand...
nah. He’s leaning substantially forward even with the angle taken into account. His shoulder is clearly forward of his foot and knee

- - - Updated - - -

Anyways. It’s irrelevant. Decision on the field of offside shouldn’t have been overturned as there is no way that’s a clear onside.
 
Vlad

Vlad

In Allegri We Trust
#2,051
May 23, 2011
22,748
#2,051
Post Ironic said:
nah. He’s leaning substantially forward even with the angle taken into account. His shoulder is clearly forward of his foot and knee
Click to expand...
I looked at it again and cant agree. Its legit to me. Id like to see image with better resolution but seems like Var is using 90s camera.
 
Vlad

Vlad

In Allegri We Trust
#2,057
May 23, 2011
22,748
#2,057
DAiDEViL said:
I'm all for the video assistent, but the moment you have to put out your ruler and check frame by frame it kinda goes to far for me.
Click to expand...
Lmao true. Either way close call and we cant reallt scream conspiracy over this. They dropped points so it softens the blow after Lecce debacle a bit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 24)