Zambrotta - Piss Poor.
Aquilani - Same position he always plays, he choked.
Panucci - Sucked.
Perrotta - Below par performances for him, which is saying something.
De Rossi - Choked.
Di Natale - Crap, overrated player.
Toni - Choked
And they all played their usual positions. So this right here is NOT Donadoni's fault.
Sure, his tactics were shit, but many Italians choked.
I'll join in...
Buffon - 6.5 - Soft-handed with the ball here, got beat once there -- but overall pretty solid.
Zambrotta - 6.5 - I actually thought he did fairly well. His defensive choices were good, and most of his crosses were decent. Did not give Spain the assists I expected.
Chiellini - 8 - I was really dismayed when the announcer would wax about Torres' great runs down the pitch, which Chiellini would absolutely destroy without even so much as an acknowledgment. He let nothing by him. Clean tackles. Threw his body in and extended himself in all the right places. A superb match and Italy's MOM.
Panucci - 5.5 - Not terrible, though not good either. One attack you'd see Torres' run in the box ripped apart by Chiellini on one end. The next run, Torres would send Panucci on his ass, rolling around on the ground with his legs flailing.
Grosso - 5.5 - A decent cross here and there and had a nice chance that Toni flicked away. But he was hazardous to Italy's health. A more eagle-eyed ref would have not tolerated his hacks in the box.
De Rossi - 5 - Added little, but gets negative points for doing very little to keep the ball and control it.
Aquilani - 5 - See De Rossi.
Perrotta - 5 - See Aquilani.
Ambrosini - 5.5 - Beat his midfield teammates only by the fact that he got himself to making more and better touches. But even then he squandered possession at most opportunities.
Cassano - 6 - Moderately constructive, but got no real help. Largely asked to do it all on his own out there.
Toni - 4.5 - It's scary when Portugal's pathetic center forwards were both far more prolific and productive than Luca Toni was in the quarterfinals. Clumsy touches. Never threatened Casillas.
Subs:
Camoranesi - 6.5- Gave Italy their best chance at a goal, even if it was slop it was at least heads-up play (Luca? Hello?). Improved the dynamics of the midfield.
Di Natale - 4.5 - Five minutes after he came on, and for the next 40 minutes of match time, I had forgotten he was on the pitch until he missed his PK.
Del Piero - NR - On too late.
Coach:
Donadoni - 5 - Lazy tactics. His subs were mixed, but mostly too little too late. Still failed to come up with a formation to get any productive use out of Toni for how many matches in a row now?