It's incredibly tough for me to vote here.
I know all of them and how do they moderate. Expectedly, many members liked the way I moderated or the way Burke, Mark and some others moderate because we were easy on them and we warn them only when they seriously go over the line, or in Mark's case, only when members go off topic in his transfer threads

Also, we always favor some members. But a good moderator is the one who follows the rules and won't include emotions in moderating.
I can see only 3 such people up there on the list.
Mikhail is one of the 3 but boy he's harsh on people and he's too robotic for me.
It leaves 2 more moderators and I won't tell their names right now (so I won't influence anyone). I will choose one of them in the following days.