Watch Materazzi's defending there
Martinez had a really good season that year, Catania in general were fun to watch, especially at home.
@The Curr
- struggled in his first year at Juve, pressure, tactical issues (Delneri's move from a 4-2-3-1/4-3-3 to a 4-4-2) and injury problems
- Conte instantly disliked him
- sent on loan to Cesena, played a dozen games, missed two large spells of the season with injuries again
- loaned to Cluj, something of a mystery but he had problems settling in and alien country, language issues, more fitness problems
- loaned to Novara, didn't play a single game. The first coach Alfredo Aglietti mostly used a 3-5-2. The later coach Alessandro Calori used a 4-2-3-1 which would suit him, but by this time he had already been blacklisted.
- loaned to Juventud in Uruguay, took some time to be considered (out of shape) and only used off the bench in a handful of later games.
We can gather from this that he has mostly been physically unfit, unprofessional, and probably a bit weak mentally.