[CL] Champions League 2012/13 (62 Viewers)

[acmilan]

Pretty close??

it's closer than it looks because the line with which you compare the goalscorer's position is the defined by the foot of the Malaga player who made that pass and he had his leg extended all the way forward. That's what I mean't.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Hængebøffer]

last defender is that guy on the goal line and Santana is between him and the GK - for there to be NO offside, Santana needs two Malaga players (field players or the GK) between him and the goal line. Here you have just one, which means offside

He thinks it's about the goalkeeper.

 

[acmilan]

But apparently the GK must be behind Dortmund's player too.

There must be two players behind to be onside.

 

[ALC]

Yeah, this same incident happened at the World Cup. Idk why RUS doesn't get it.

- - - Updated - - -

it's closer than it looks because the line with which you compare the goalscorer's position is the defined by the foot of the Malaga player who made that pass and he had his leg extended all the way forward. That's what I mean't.

Yeah, after I looked at the vid again I was surprised how much closer it was than I previously thought

 

[acmilan]

Drogba

We would not have been in this situation had we got Drogba instead of Anelka.

you'd have been a proper contender in that case.

 

[X Æ A-12]

How the fuck did you get this from what I wrote?

Because you said that the position of Goalkeeper doesn't matter and that's incorrect He counts as any other defensive player.

 

[calmyournerves]

The position of the GK doesn't matter. All players count.

 

[Hængebøffer]

Because you said that the position of Goalkeeper doesn't matter and that's incorrect He counts as any other defensive player.

I know that now
It's because it seemed like people forgot, that the goalkeeper is just like any player on the field when it comes to offside.

 

[ALC]

The position of the GK doesn't matter. All players count.

And the GK himself is a player. thus, his position does matter. As does every other player's position.

 

[Juventino[RUS]]

The position of the GK doesn't matter. All players count.

 

[GarfielD]

Do keepers hands count?

 

[Alen]

It's easy ffs. Here, from FIFA.com


http://www.fifa.com/mm/document/afdeveloping/refereeing/5. law 11_554.pdf

A PLAYER IS IN OFFSIDE POSITION IF:
Nearer to his opponents’ goal line than both the ball and the second last opponent.

In Dortmund's last goal, the goalkeeper puts Santana offside. It's too clear.

 

[Hængebøffer]

And the GK himself is a player. thus, his position does matter. As does every other player's position.

It's not wrong what he's writing, but you can interpret it in two different ways.

 

[j0ker]

Some here won't get it no matter what.

 

[calmyournerves]

Who doesn't get it?

 

[Alen]

Some here won't get it no matter what.

It comes as a shock, I know very well. Some 4-5 years ago Trez scored such a goal and I argued that it wasn't offside. But in the end, I learned that it was, and Trez himself said that it's offside. It's just that 99.9% of the offsides are called because there is only one player in front of the attacker (the goalkeeper) and there needs to be two players. With time, we simply forgot to count the goalkeeper

 

[Gheorghe Hagi]

The Galatasaray come back begins @Gheorghe Hagi

Almost buddy. We might have eliminated Madrid alone, but not with the refs on their side in both matches.

Unlucky Gala... they just don't have a Ronaldo.

We had "El Comandante" Hagi back in the day. I'd take Hagi over Ronaldo hundred, thousand, million times if I had the chance today. I don't think we will ever see a player like Hagi again in our team.

 

[Badass J Elkann]

He's finished they said.

i wanted him so badly in January, hope the doubters choke on a fat one, they know who they are

 

[Gheorghe Hagi]

poor hagi

 

[Badass J Elkann]

glad you're taking the funny side to elimination