The only real problem I have with Pirlo is that he makes us so completely susceptible to counter-attacks. I think that's why we played so conservatively against Shakhtar. Shakhtar is an enormously successful counter-attacking team with their quick Brazilians. Pirlo, playing as essentially the first guy in front of the defense is completely useless against a counter attack. He just has no shot to recover. It's just the trade-off you're going to have to deal with when you have a guy like him in the lineup.
It's not that he doesn't have the work rate, he just doesn't have the pace. I mean, if even one of Vidal or Marchisio gets caught up front, which is an easy thing to do, our defence is completely exposed centrally. And if Bonucci has to step up in front of the defence we're in trouble because he can't do it.
The 3-5-2 really is in place to slow our game down and make it more of a possession or counter attack game for us, not an up and down game like we had with the 4-3-3.
I do like the 3-5-2 but I'd like to see a 4-3-3 with Marchisio, Vidal and Asamoah all in the center. I'd like to see us try and go up and down some games without fear.
I wonder what would have happened if we went to a 4-3-3 with those horses in the middle against Shakhtar and just traded blows. I don't think their defence could have handled it. I think we would have won out.