Search results

  1. Trequartista

    Trans people: your informed opinions and why you hold them

    I hadn't seen the date. However, is there any other kind of mental disorder for which we advocate surgery rather than therapy?
  2. Trequartista

    Trans people: your informed opinions and why you hold them

    Fair enough :D - - - Updated - - - So, should we fund and encourage reassignment surgery despite the evidence for it actually making them happier very slim? Apparently, a significant portion of them regret the surgery and attempt suicide...
  3. Trequartista

    Trans people: your informed opinions and why you hold them

    Oh for sure, but I've heard many feminist saying both that gender is a social construct and that transgenders have the soul/brain of the other sex.
  4. Trequartista

    Trans people: your informed opinions and why you hold them

    You hit the nail on the head here. There is a contradiction in the social equality movement as feminists have been claiming for decades that gender is a social construct and that there are no differences between men and women biologically in terms of brain structure and other things. Now they...
  5. Trequartista

    Trans people: your informed opinions and why you hold them

    How about body integrity identity disorder, that's surely a birth defect as well. Should we pay for their surgery to have their limbs hacked off too? How about people suffering from the Cotard delusion, who they that they are dead. Should we pay for their euthanasia?
  6. Trequartista

    Trans people: your informed opinions and why you hold them

    You guys know that now they block homornes of teenagers who claim that they have the soul of the other sex? I can't see how one can be seriously be ok with that, as if a teenager knew enough about sexuality and gender identity to understand that.
  7. Trequartista

    Trans people: your informed opinions and why you hold them

    They regard it as a birth defect I guess? For masectomies, it is usually done to prevent/treat cancer, right? - - - Updated - - - Sure, definitions are irrelevant.
  8. Trequartista

    Trans people: your informed opinions and why you hold them

    Ok. So the government/insurance companies pay for reassignment surgeries because it's a mental disorder. Yet, LGBT groups keep saying that transgenderism is not a mental disorder. However, there is no way insurant companies would want to pay for it if it weren't a mental disorder, otherwise one...
  9. Trequartista

    Trans people: your informed opinions and why you hold them

    A birth defect? So let's be clear about this, trans people think they have the soul/brain of the opposite sex. So it's a mental disorder, right?
  10. Trequartista

    Trans people: your informed opinions and why you hold them

    I'm not sure if they pay for all of them, but I do know that in several countries reassignment surgery falls under health coverage, like in Canada. So the question is, why would the government/insurance companies pay for reassignment surgery?
  11. Trequartista

    Trans people: your informed opinions and why you hold them

    It's pretty straightforward :D
  12. Trequartista

    Trans people: your informed opinions and why you hold them

    I have a simple question: why do insurance companies/public health care pay for reassignment surgery?