The past season it's probably been Bonucci tbh, but yeah, it's incredible. Most underrated player I've ever seen.
- - - Updated - - -
Ah, you meant over the past 5 seasons overall. My bad.
whoscored ratings for defenders don't mean shit
But yeah, sadly think his days as a starter are over next season, still can be an amazing backup if he wants to and no serious injury happens.
On his best, he's equally good to be fair.
Just way more inconsistent. On the other hand of course Bonucci has some other qualities Barzagli simply doesn't, is hugely important in our playstyle and scores those crucial goals we all love.